I wear It CC cream sometimes...but even though I wear it, I don't recommend it, because it really needs a primer underneath (which totally defeats the purpose, since it's supposed to be all-in-one, and you're looking for something more simple) or it sinks into lines and pores as the day goes on. Although I do love their bye bye under eye...but a little goes a loooooooooong way.
I'm a fan of tarte products, and even though it's a foundation and not tinted moisturizer, I would suggest their Rainforest of the Sea line. Good, buildable coverage, and one of the most natural looking foundations I've EVER used. And I've tried a lot (like, a lot a lot!) of different types.
For a tinted moisturizer I really like Origins VitaZing with mangosteen. It has spf, and gives a nice glow. If you use too much, it can look a little streaky (because it starts out white and turns skin color as it's applied), so I blend it with a beauty blender. Otherwise, it's a favorite of mine!
Good luck! I have searched and searched over the years, and just now feel like I'm getting a good grasp on what I like the most. It takes a lot of trial and error, which is the good part about trying things out at Sephora, since they'll give you samples.