Great thread and it came at the perfect time!
My DH and I are trying to make this decision as well and we don't know what to do. In the last house we owned we had a garden tub, no jets and we both used it. Mostly, me but he got in it once in a while. It really got a lot of use whenever I had a cold or some other kind of sickness. It was on a platform in a corner, but wasn't built as a corner tub. It was a standard size and 2 people was a really tight squeeze.
Now, we are looking at building and we found the perfect floorplan and in building costs, the builder includes a standard size garden tub like we had before.
DH and I first considered reconfiguring the bathroom to accomodate a 2 person (air jetted) corner tub (like those at OKW) but then thought that it might use too much water. Also to upgrade to that is an additional 7K.
Then we thought of maybe putting the same standard size that is already shown in the floor plan with jets which is considerably less.
Now we've gone back to thinking that maybe we should just stick with the garden tub like we've had before and leave it at that. We are just so confused. We want to choose something that we would be really happy with because this will be our forever home since it is on river-front family land.
Would we regret just sticking with a garden tub?