Thinking about purchasing the Nikon D5300…any thoughts?

reesecup

DIS Veteran
Joined
Nov 20, 2004
Messages
533
Wondering what some thoughts on the Nikon D5300….is there another camera in the same price range that might be a better purchase? I think I would still prefer the dslr cameras over the mirror less .

Also, any advice on a good zoom lens?

Thanks!
 
Some thoughts...
  • Great choice.
  • If you don't need the flipout screen.... save money to get the D3300.
  • D7100 offers better features and AF motor for cheaper legacy lenses.
What's your current camera? Do you use the zoom a lot?
  • best zoom choice is the 70-200mm f/2.8 for low light and image quality. But the price is very high. It's a choice down the road if you like your camera a lot.
  • there's the 70-300mm that's a popular choice
  • 55-200mm is a popular second choice, but people don't like the lens swap.
  • I like the superzooms for practicality. Image quality is not so good, but no lens swaps. Nikon offers the 18-200mm and 18-300mm.
 
Thank you so much for your input! I currently have the Nikon D90 and have really loved it but I had a part that broke and thought we had fixed it but when I put my lens (the 55-200 mm …which I have loved) on, I can no longer take it off! So, I'm going to keep this one but wanted to get another camera with a new lens or two. I do love the 55-200 but my camera does get heavy. I love the zoom on it though!

I think I would like to try the 70-200 since you say it is good for low light and then get a good standard lens…any suggestions on that? Thanks again
 
Nikon makes a 24-120 f/4 lens that's a great walk around lens. Expensive but good. The 18-200 is much less pricey and is still a good solid lens. I would stick with at least the d5300 level camera. My favorite lenses are the 70-200 (super $$$ and heavy but awesome) and the 105 macro. I use a 24-120 for walking around. Good luck!
 

Truthfully, all the cameras in the similar price range, will give you very similar performance. Some slight differences in features and image quality, but not enough differences to say one camera is "better" than another. For example, some might like the touch screen on the Canon Rebel, while the Nikon will give you slightly higher resolution and more dynamic range.

For your use and my assumptions on your budget, you don't want the 70-200/2.8. It is a fantastic lens -- it also weighs a brick and costs over $2000.

If you are looking for a good general purpose telephoto zoom, I'd look at the Tamron 70-300 usd.
For a regular standard zoom, the Nikon 18-55, the basic kit lens, is very solid.
Personally, I'd stay away from super zooms like the 18-300. For me, the convenience isn't worth the image quality sacrifice.
 
The D5300 comes with a 18-140 mm lens, and I have been very happy with this lens. It gives good overall performance and flexibility. For me it was worth the purchase, and I have really enjoyed my D5300.
 
D5300 is an excellent choice. Grab the one kit zoom (maybe the 18-55) or whatever comes with it. But also ick up the 35mm Dx prime.
 
Oh, thank you all so much! To make things more confusing though, I have since started wondering if the 7100 is worth the extra few hundred dollar difference (or at least that is about the price difference I'm showing)……So….thoughts on the 7100 to the 5300, now?? Again, my current is the D90 but thinking about selling it but I would have to sell it with the lens attached since I can not remove it for whatever reason. Thanks!
 
Oh, thank you all so much! To make things more confusing though, I have since started wondering if the 7100 is worth the extra few hundred dollar difference (or at least that is about the price difference I'm showing)……So….thoughts on the 7100 to the 5300, now?? Again, my current is the D90 but thinking about selling it but I would have to sell it with the lens attached since I can not remove it for whatever reason. Thanks!

Depends on your type of shooting. If you're an "auto" shooter, only using a couple basic kit lenses, etc... Then the D5300 is all you really need. The image quality is virtually identical between the cameras. They likely use the same sensor, so really will produce the same images, when used in the same way.
The D7100 has a number of enhancements, most of which are designed for more advanced users. They are definitely worthwhile features for such users, but meaningless for some.
Among the enhancement everyone will notice: The D7100 has a much nicer viewfinder. If you held them side by side, you would notice the D7100 viewfinder is brighter and larger. If you looked at the D7100 first, and then held the D5300 to your eye, it would feel like a small dark tunnel. The D7100 also covers the entire image in the viewfinder, the D5300 cuts off the edges.

The next big difference is the level of manual controls. Both cameras let you take manual control. But the D7100 has far more buttons and dials, to make it easy for an advanced user to change every possible setting. For example, two control dials, so the advanced user can change both aperture and shutter speed at the same time. The D5300 lets you make manual adjustments, but you need to dive through more menus to do so. Thus, it's faster and easier to make manual adjustments on the D7100. For some users, this is a big deal. For others, pretty meaningless.

The D7100 has a more advanced autofocus system. But the D5300 isn't a slouch. Alone, it's not a reason to spend extra.

The D7100 has 2 media card slots, the D5300 only has 1. So if you want a "back up" memory card, or want to save RAW files on 1 card, and save JPEG files on another card, at the same time, the D7100 lets you do it.

The D7100 is weather sealed, the D5300 isn't. In practice, a few drops of rain isn't going to break the D5300. But if you want to use your camera in a hurricane or blizzard, you're better off with the D7100.

The D7100 has a much longer battery.

The D7100 can shoot at 1/8000 of a second, the D5300 is limited to 1/4000. This is irrelevant for 99% of shooters, 99% of the time... but if you want to shoot at 1.4 aperture, in the bright sunlight, then you need that 1/8000!

D7100 has 6fps vs 5 fps on the D5300.... But they both have poor buffers, so neither camera is a great sports shooter.

This is big for some people: The D7100 has an auto focus motor, enabling you to use every AF Nikon lens built in the last 50 years. The D5300 lacks the motor, so it can only use the newer Nikon lenses. Again, irrelevant if you are just using a couple newer kit lenses. Very relevant if you want to use some very old very good lenses, or some of the Nikon specialty lenses that still require a motor.

Those are the differences I can think of. You need to figure out if any of those differences are meaningful to you. I would go with the D7100, but I'm a pretty advanced shooter, and like having the extra manual controls, and the larger viewfinder.
 
Depends on your type of shooting. If you're an "auto" shooter, only using a couple basic kit lenses, etc... Then the D5300 is all you really need. The image quality is virtually identical between the cameras. They likely use the same sensor, so really will produce the same images, when used in the same way.
The D7100 has a number of enhancements, most of which are designed for more advanced users. They are definitely worthwhile features for such users, but meaningless for some.
Among the enhancement everyone will notice: The D7100 has a much nicer viewfinder. If you held them side by side, you would notice the D7100 viewfinder is brighter and larger. If you looked at the D7100 first, and then held the D5300 to your eye, it would feel like a small dark tunnel. The D7100 also covers the entire image in the viewfinder, the D5300 cuts off the edges.

The next big difference is the level of manual controls. Both cameras let you take manual control. But the D7100 has far more buttons and dials, to make it easy for an advanced user to change every possible setting. For example, two control dials, so the advanced user can change both aperture and shutter speed at the same time. The D5300 lets you make manual adjustments, but you need to dive through more menus to do so. Thus, it's faster and easier to make manual adjustments on the D7100. For some users, this is a big deal. For others, pretty meaningless.

The D7100 has a more advanced autofocus system. But the D5300 isn't a slouch. Alone, it's not a reason to spend extra.

The D7100 has 2 media card slots, the D5300 only has 1. So if you want a "back up" memory card, or want to save RAW files on 1 card, and save JPEG files on another card, at the same time, the D7100 lets you do it.

The D7100 is weather sealed, the D5300 isn't. In practice, a few drops of rain isn't going to break the D5300. But if you want to use your camera in a hurricane or blizzard, you're better off with the D7100.

The D7100 has a much longer battery.

The D7100 can shoot at 1/8000 of a second, the D5300 is limited to 1/4000. This is irrelevant for 99% of shooters, 99% of the time... but if you want to shoot at 1.4 aperture, in the bright sunlight, then you need that 1/8000!

D7100 has 6fps vs 5 fps on the D5300.... But they both have poor buffers, so neither camera is a great sports shooter.

This is big for some people: The D7100 has an auto focus motor, enabling you to use every AF Nikon lens built in the last 50 years. The D5300 lacks the motor, so it can only use the newer Nikon lenses. Again, irrelevant if you are just using a couple newer kit lenses. Very relevant if you want to use some very old very good lenses, or some of the Nikon specialty lenses that still require a motor.

Those are the differences I can think of. You need to figure out if any of those differences are meaningful to you. I would go with the D7100, but I'm a pretty advanced shooter, and like having the extra manual controls, and the larger viewfinder.


Great information here! Thanks for the detailed info! :) Now, I'm really leaning toward the 7100. xlxo….that is interesting…I need to save up some money so maybe the 7200 will come out by then and I can get the 7100 cheaper! Thanks everyone for your advice!
 
But the D7100 has far more buttons and dials, to make it easy for an advanced user to change every possible setting. For example, two control dials, so the advanced user can change both aperture and shutter speed at the same time. The D5300 lets you make manual adjustments, but you need to dive through more menus to do so. Thus, it's faster and easier to make manual adjustments on the D7100. For some users, this is a big deal. For others, pretty meaningless.

The D7100 is weather sealed, the D5300 isn't. In practice, a few drops of rain isn't going to break the D5300. But if you want to use your camera in a hurricane or blizzard, you're better off with the D7100.

The extra buttons provides the user with quicker access to common features. One complaint with cheaper cameras is the need to go through menu's to get the most common features.

Weather seals get better with each more expensive Nikon.
  • Weather seals are great when coming out of an air conditioned room and into a tropical climate.
  • do not put a camera into a wet camera bag. While cameras can tolerate a few showers, camera battery doors often let water into the camera from the bottom.
  • your camera may be sealed... your lens is likely not. Beware of lens fungas.
 
I have both the D90 and the D5200, the D90 is still my favorite camera but when I go to WDW I take my D5200 with the 18-200mm as the walkaround lens. I also have the 18-140mm, and have been very pleased with it also (it is a good lens considering it is a kit lens). The only drawback I experienced when trying out the D7100 was the additional weight and the body having more depth making it less comfortable in my hands. Most of the photographers I know say it is not the camera body necessarily but the glass, so go with what you are comfortable with and you can't go wrong.
 
I am going to go a little against the grain here. I sold my D7000 for a D5200, and I now own a D5300. I made the decision because I wanted a lighter and smaller camera.

I do miss the larger viewfinder on the D7XXX cameras, but I have adapted to the manual adjustments on the D5200 and D5300 without difficulty. You do *not* need to go into the menu system to change aperture, shutter speed, and ISO - the three of these can be changed quickly and easily. You just hold down a different button while turning the dial. If you need to change more than those three basic settings (such as changing white balance), then you will need to go into the menu system.

Also, if you can get a good deal on the body alone, I would argue against purchasing a kit lens. That's a bigger discussion, but I think you will find many better quality lenses for not much more than the cost of a kit lens, some made by Sigma and/or Tamron.
 
I have had the D5300 now for a little over 7 months and really enjoy the camera. As Trstno1 pointed out you do not need to go into the menus to make adjustments - I can adjust the ISO, Aperture and Shutter Speed all while looking through the view finder. It is an excellent camera to start with and get you feet wet, and can serve you well for sometime. Kit lens was a good starting point for me (18-140 mm) and allowed me get started and really learn what other options/lenses I wanted to add.

Whatever you decide, spend some time behind the lens and really looking critically at the results. Try to understand the photographic triangle as best as possible. I would consider looking at some online courses and books. They are INVALUABLE in my opinion and money well spent.
 
Thank you everyone! I am thinking since I've had the D90 for many years now, that maybe the D7000 will be more of a change for me. BUT, I do like the idea of lighter and being able to adjust ISO, Aperture and Shutter Speed through the view finder.

TheBigE -- what are some online courses you took? I don't know if you can recommend one to me on here but I don't want to get scammed.
I do have a lot to learn. I've gotten some decent shots over the years but I think it was more of taking a ton of pics and getting kind of lucky (with a little knowledge). I want to learn so much more. Thank you all again!
 
TheBigE -- what are some online courses you took? I don't know if you can recommend one to me on here but I don't want to get scammed.
I do have a lot to learn. I've gotten some decent shots over the years but I think it was more of taking a ton of pics and getting kind of lucky (with a little knowledge). I want to learn so much more. Thank you all again!

Sorry for delay in responding, I just returned from vacation. Anyways, I took course Understanding Exposure from Bryan Peterson School of Photography. It was really worth the time and money I spent. Not sure if I will get in trouble with DIS but here is a link to a review I did on the course. Bryan's Book Understand Exposure has also been a really great resource for me as well, and also worth the investment.
 












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom