Just got flights all booked! Unfortunately SW didn’t have a flight back at the time I wanted (we live in DC—I refuse to do a layover on a 2 hr direct flight), so I cobbled together a Frankenstein itinerary. SW down to Orlando (my flight was free, thank you points!) and then Jet Blue (with 1 free checked bag per person) on the way back. All in all not too shabby for $326 or so for both me and DH. Huzzah!
Now just have to wait til next month to book ADRs....