Disregarding who we feel Bella is destined to be with, who would YOU date: Edward or Jacob?
Personally, I would date Edward. He seems like he'd be ok just staying in his room, listening to music and cuddling (which is what I do all day unless I'm by myself, which is a lot). Jacob seems like the type of guy who always needs to be doing something. Edward also listens to good music, which helps his case extremely.
Edward is also more romantic and loving than Jacob. Jacob seemed really aggressive when kissing Bella, while Edward was always very gentle with her (even when he was feeling...urgent).
Edward seems, in my opinion, better looking than Jacob. I'm a sucker (heh) for pale skinned boys.
Weirdly, I don't really like excessively warm people. It makes me feel sticky. I'm always cold like ice, so it wouldn't be a big deal (it can be 104, and my hands and feet will be frigid).