Letthewookiewin dont mind at all. Being able to experience both a garden view and a Magic Kingdom view at the same cost made me first realize that we were lucky to get the upgrade and second the value of having a great view really adds to the trip. Both my girls are sensitive to really load noises and will not watch the fireworks while at the Magic Kingdom (if we are still at the park we are always ducking into somewhere when the fireworks start) so to be able to watch them from our balcony while eating a late meal was great.
Your comment makes me want to upgrade to a Theme Park View for our upcoming trip. Last time we had a Garden View and it was really nice (Fiji, overlooking the marina) but to see the castle from our room would be so magical, especially at night! But is it really worth an extra $700+ for 5 nights?!
They had GV right across the hallway from us. Either way you go you will have a wonderful vacation at the Poly. Where is Wisconsin are you from? Our one daughter is in Rhinelander, WI. It is so beautiful up there and the people are so friendly. 
But I'm afraid it could very well happen leaving Downtown Disney
) The Poly concierge upgraded both of our daughters & their families to concierge GV rooms. As I said in the above post they had the rooms right across the hall from us. This was such a magical trip for us all. It felt as if all of us had received a "dream" staying together in the Hawaii longhouse.
I am not sure who felt blessed more, my kids or me.
The concierge CM's went beyond any possible dream I had for our family.
pixie dust and warm wishes for an upgrade.
I joined AAA just for the Disney discounts! I don't even drive 
. Not my thing. I decided to spend the extra money to have the convenience of the monorail. Like a PP said there is the other alternative of a Garden Wing room at CR. HTH!