Ok... First: breathe. Then look at Ellery. You have kept her alive this long because you are a responsible, sensible, caring Mommy. You are doing a GOOD JOB.
Now: The tylenol will not damage her liver unless you give her entire bottles every night (or unless she already had liver problems or a confirmed issue metabolizing medicines). The warnings are there for idiot parents who overdose their kids to shut them up. Or, idiot parents who give their kids cold meds AND tylenol AND motrin... You are not an idiot parent. You will measure out the correct dose for her weight and then give that to her and you won't give her another dose until it's time (by which time she'll be sleeping peacefully). Also, you can minimize risk by alternating Motrin and Tylenol, ensuring that you won't OD on one med since they are different kinds.
She will be ok.
And, the baby orajel thing? I mean- that's a "gut" issue. V's doc reccommended it in small doses. Personally, I have used orajel on myself for toothaches, and in small amounts, I have never had my throat go numb. I put a small (tiny!) amount on a "finger brush" (baby gum cleaner), and rubbed it only on her gums.
The teething tablets- I just dug out our bottle. Here's what I found on the website concerning the belladonna (keep in mind: ANY medicine is poison if you ingest too much!!): "To put homeopathic dosages in perspective, typically a 10-pound child would need to ingest 1,000 Hylands Teething Tablets (at least 6 bottles of 125 tablets) to exhibit even the first possible side effect of Belladonna." You can look at that page
here.
And really, I bet you'll find that one small dose of Tylenol or Motrin each night will be all you need- during the day it doesn't bother them much because they are busy busy.
Ellery is a healthy growing beautiful baby girl because you are careful and you are responsible. But, because she is healthy and growing so perfectly, you don't need to worry about giving her a dose of Tylenol or Motrin. You'll BOTH feel better!