Hi all. Not that you asked, but I thought I'd share some things that I think are of value as follows:
1. Booking your vacation
2. The Disney Meal Plan
3. My observations/comparisons on CR vs. Others
4. My observations on the parks and pre-Christmas Visit
1.0 Booking the vacation
We discovered several things about getting the best price possible on booking your vacation.
1.1 Disney Visa Card. If you are going to be going to Disney, it makes tremendous sense to have the Disney Visa card via Chase. You get offers about a week before they are made public, you get disney reward dollars earned on your purchases etc. We had over $500 DRD built up in two years simply by charging our normal spending and office purchases on the Disney card and paying them off immediately. These DRD can be used on anything Disney, room and board, dinning, spending splurges, photopass etc. Plus your room and board is 6 months same as cash if charged.
1.2 Don't stop shopping your package price until 45 days prior to departure, when the penalty is charged. We changed our package on day 47 prior because a better offer was available. Our rebooking for the exact same items saved us $150 AND got us an upgraded room.
1.3 If you want to save time and hassle, use a disney vacation specialist. This is the second time we used ours, and you get the exact same pricing offered through Disney direct. They can price any special offers etc the exact same as Disney direct. Disney reservations does not give you discounts or special offers unless you know about them and ask for them, and they won't automatically give you the best available. Specialists are paid a booking fee and in most instances they are trying to beat a deal you already know about, so they search aggressively for the best deals.
1.4 You really need to understand the pricing of individual components of your plan. In our case, the offer with the free meal plan if we paid rack rate was better than the discounted room rate we originally booked, but only because we were going to buy the meal plan anyway.
2.0 Disney meal plan
I've always stressed over whether to buy the meal plan or not as far as dollars spent. This time I saved every meal receipt while on the meal plan and can make an exact analysis.
2.1 If you want to minimize your food budget, the meal plan IS NOT the way to do it. You will do much better having garden grocer deliver some bread/sandwhich meats, cereal etc.
2.2 Even if minimizing your food budget isn't a concern, you will do better without the meal plan. Dollar for dollar, meal for meal. I know they are introducing a counter-service meal plan for next year, maybe my opinion will change.
2.3 With the meal plan changes the tip is now excluded from the plan, and we found service to be lacking every place where we notified them we were using a meal plan. (At checkin at the sit-down restaurants.) In fact, in general, this has been the worst service we have received at Disney sit-down restaurants. I suspect meal planners haven't been leaving tips.
2.4 On counter-service redemptions, your children do not have to use the child's menu, they can get an adult combo meal.
2.5 Breakfast counter service includes two beverages, so you can get a bottle of water with your coffee etc and take the water for later.
2.6 To maximize the meal plan, book character meal buffets and special seatings, like the Dinner and Candlelight processional at Epcot or Dinner and Fantasmic at Hollywood studios. These are $35 and up packages that include guaranteed, no-wait seating to these shows, and is only one meal redemption. The character buffets are also pretty pricey, as are things like Germany in Epcot, but they only cost one redemption. For our fantasmic package, the ticket price for that one meal was the same as the price for the entire meal plan for that day, and was only one redemption. In other words, it gives you incentive to splurge on meals you might not otherwise book.
3.0 CR vs. Others
This was our fist time at the CR. PReviously I have stayed at All Stars Movies in 06 and Dixie Landings in 95. Prior to that off-property at Disney Tree Houses.
3.1 We were upgraded to a bay tower room from a booked water view garden wing room.
3.2 The bedding was wonderful, top notch. Bathrooms were nice. Room spacious. Having the computer and refrigerator in room meant I didn't have to lug a laptop and we could have garden grocer deliver 12 packs of whatever soda we drank right to our room for the cost of 2 refillable mugs.
3.3 The CR is the loudest of the properties I have stayed at. (Well, the peacocks at the Tree Houses were pretty loud.)
3.4 We prefer the food-court setups of the other on-property hotels. No ice cream shop in the CR cafe.

3.5 The CR being convenient to the monorail really changed the dynamic for us. We were encouraged to take mid-day breaks and we actually napped 4 days between 2-4. This was a huge quality of trip boost.
3.6 The shopping at CR is the best of any hotel we've visited including the Grand Floridian.
3.7 The housekeeping is average to slightly below average from what we have had at other Disney properties, and we left a tip envelope every day from day one.
4.0 Disney pre-christmas
This is our second week-before-christmas visit. We still think it is *the* time to visit disney. The decorations, mood and atmosphere is wonderful, and you don't have the simply beastily heat and humidity you get during other times.
4.1 I think the word is getting out, because the crowds this year were huge, headline attractions routinely had 80-120 minute standby times.
4.2 If you are going to fantasmic or Candlelight Processional (really wonderful, must see) consider one of the "dinner and a show" packages. people were waiting in line for 3 hours for Candlelight processional and did not get in. Having guaranteed, no wait seating is worth the price of these packages.
4.3 The airline industry is reallly slipping. Over 50% of our flying had to be rebooked from the airport. This was three different airlines, 4 different airports, so it seems to be systemic failure. I have a friend who is a senior co-pilot for a large airline flying south america and europe. his family gets free airfare everywhere, and he says if it is an 8 hour or less drive they drive. I really understand why now. We ended up buying 2 additional tickets to avoid spending the night in an airport on Christmas Eve simply because continental refused to re-book weather related delays on available flights on partner airlines.
4.4 We did not do the magical christmas party this year and honestly didn't miss it. We talked to folks who went and they said the ride lines were still long. The parade and holiday wishes fireworks show you get on non-party nights is the same as the one at the party. Seems like the christmas party tickets are expensive cups of cocoa. It also snows on non-christmas party nights, too.
Well, that is it. I could ramble more, but I think that is the information I'd share with a friend who was planning a trip. If budget allows, CR will be our hotel from now on, but if budget doesn't allow but WOULD allow All Stars or some other hotel, we wouldn't hesitate to go to one of the "downstream" hotels.