Did you look at the character meal photo thread I posted the link for? Anything jump out at you yet? Unfortunately, I don't think anyone has posted any photos of the new Surf's Up with Mickey meal at the PPH (which used to be the Lilo and Stitch Aloha Breakfast) yet, but because Mickey is there, I am sure it is very popular. When I ate at Goofy's Kitchen on the 19th, some of the CMs there were telling us how swamped the PCH Grill has been with people clamoring to see Mickey since that meal opened.
Just to clarify about the character meals a little more -
Goofy's Kitchen, whether it be for breakfast/brunch or dinner, is an all you can eat, serve yourself, buffet - tons of selections. I personally have never been a fan of the dinner buffet - but truthfully, I didn't give it enough of a chance. I only tried the dinner buffet one or two times (I thought it was once but a friend reminded me we ate there another time for dinner!), and neither time was I very hungry so nothing really appealed to me. Also, just because of my own preferences, I like breakfast offerings better than dinner. And breakfast is cheaper than dinner! However, there are lots of people who strongly prefer the dinner buffet - even some who did not like Goofy's at all at breakfast but enjoyed it for dinner very much. So I think it is just up to the individual person what they like. I have been eating the breakfast buffet at Goofy's since 1992, and the characters have varied over the years, but when we were there 2 weeks ago, we saw 8 characters in the restaurant and took photos with 6 of them. (Also, the food was even better than it had been on my last few visits.) There was Max, Goofy, Chip, Dale, Belle and Mulan, and then working the other side of the restaurant were Pluto and another Princess (I forget who it was). Often times, Jasmine, Aladdin, Baloo, Aurora and the Prince, Alice and the Mad Hatter are there in the morning, too, and people report seeing Captain Hook, Minnie, the Genie and other fun types at night.
Here is a link to one page of Disneynerd420s TR, with recent, extensive photos of the Goofys buffet just scroll all the way down the page and see all the great photos. Even though these are breakfast photos and not dinner, you will get an idea of how extensive the dinner buffet will be (I dont know of any recent TRs with a lot of photos of the other character buffets, or I would post those too):
http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=2268157&page=23
Storytellers Cafe Critter Breakfast also has an all you can eat, serve yourself, buffet at breakfast. I recommend the buffet because the off-the-menu items are outrageously expensive for what they are and the buffet makes more sense. This buffet is much, much smaller than Goofy's, with fewer choices, but some folks prefer it over all the other character meals because of the laid-back, low key atmosphere (whereas Goofys is more high octane fun and Minnie & Friends can be a bit chaotic, form what folks say). I have done this meal 3 times, and I am not a big fan of the food at the Critter Breakfast and neither was my friend, who had never eaten at Storytellers OR at Goofy's before, until this year. She preferred Goofy's by a mile, even though she had to shell out a lot of $$$ for it. However,
many people love the food at Storytellers - so again, it is all personal opinion and taste. I think 3 times was enough for me, unless someone I am with just
has to go there! Storytellers Cafe is a nice, earthy kind of restaurant that lends itself well to the woodsy/jungly characters who visit there. Chip and Dale are always there. Koda and Kenai from Brother Bear are always there. Terk from Tarzan is usually there. Meeko from Pocahontas is sometimes there. People have reported seeing Baloo (rarely) and a Brer character or two, once in a blue moon.
Minnie & Friends seems to have the most characters on premises of all of the character meals - sometimes they overlap 'shifts,' so you might get a bonanza of characters all at one time. And it is cheaper than Goofys and the new Surfs Up with Mickey meal, which is a big plus! This is not the typical all you can eat buffet set-up. This is served 'buffeteria style,' but you can go back for seconds. I have not tried this one yet because there have consistently been mixed reviews on the food quality. While there are tons of characters (Chip, Dale, Captain Hook, Fairy Godmother, Pooh, Tigger, sometimes Eeyore and Piglet, Max, and many, many more), I have repeatedly heard that the food is often cold or just bland and not up to par, even though everyone agrees the character interaction is great. But the folks who love Minnie & Friends LOVE it and say the food is great. Only you can decide what you like! I still intend to try it eventually, just for the characters if nothing else.
I have not eaten at the
Ariel's Grotto Princess meal for breakfast, lunch or dinner - simply because I have no interest in Princesses! But people consistently rave about the menu there and how good the food is - and it seems to be unique in contrast to any other character meal. Plus, if you have little ones who love Princesses, this is the place to go to be sure to see them (even though there are usually at least 2 Princesses at Goofy's, it is not guaranteed they will be there, so Ariel's is the go-to place for definite Princess meetings).
The early reports on the
Surfs Up with Mickey meal is that it is buffet only (no more menu orders), and aside from Mickey, Daisy Duck is there, Surfer Goofy, Minnie and sometimes Pluto are there, as well as Lilo and Stitch, or any combination of the above. There are a few unique food items with Polynesian or Latin influence mixed in with the regular breakfast fare. I look forward to trying this one hopefully whenever I make my next trip to DLR.