We ate several meals there in November...we stayed at the YC. There were 7 of us. Most of us had steak and we all enjoyed it. It is 1 ts restaurant. It is pretty quiet and out of the way. No character meals.
I would recommend it.
I can't answer from personal experience, but my MIL liked the steak she had at Captain's Grille better than the one she had at Le Cellier the night before.
My DH had the boubon steak and did not care for it, but we had eaten an amazing meal at Le Cellier 2 nights before and any steak would be a letdown at that point. My DD and I had the crab legs and they were really good. None of us really cared for our desserts.