RobDoc
DIS Legend
- Joined
- Aug 14, 1998
- Messages
- 34,195
Dean said:A bit sensitive are we? The fact that there is some subjectivity to even the most stringent of scientific study or resort rating system does not remove it's usefulness completely. Even the articles in the top Dental or Medical journal are tainted by big business and Pharmaceutical and hardware companies. And while one might agree or disagree on the ratings of Mobile, AAA or any other system, there is at least some objectivity in most of them and even when there's not and it's all subjective, taking a broader sampling will generally offer a more accurate evaluation. And dollars will ultimately tell the tale in most any area. Try offering a DVC HH rental vs a beach rental and see what happens.
If someone stays at DVC HH and no where else and loves it, that' is fine. They have nothing to prove to anyone else, are free to enjoy that experience and free to say how much they enjoy it. NO one said it wasn't a nice resort only that there were some even nicer overall. However, they have no basis to compare to any other resort or area unless they have some type of experience or specific knowledge to base it on. I believe many DVC members do not, many haven't even been to HH at all.
I don't know your opinion or experience with the Marriott's, I don't recall you've ever said other than you haven't stayed ocean front if I recall eliminating the best Marriott's. But if you have an opinion, I'd love to hear it and what you base it on and can promise you that it won't bother me at all no matter how bad it is. I've stayed at a number of resorts all over HH including DVC and Marriott's Harbour Pointe and Sunset Pointe just across the water, it's easy to compare rental rates within the Marriott system. Yet my opinion is still that, just my opinion. But it is certainly more informed on this subject than many DVC members, likely less than others, why does that bother you?
I suspect DVC resorts are not included in TST because they require non members to rate them and there just aren't that many non members who stay there. Unfortunately TST doesn't get nearly as much traffic in this area and they don't give you how the data was arrived at quite as much as TUG does. Even II and RCI do not do double blind, randomized, controlled, prospective studies in this area so if you want to discount all else but your own feelings, that is certainly your option. BTW, TST's 10 pt rating system used to be a 5 pt rating system.
Not a bit sensitive- as I'm very comfortable with my personal opinion and my experiences both with DVC resorts and a host of other timeshare locations. I do take exception with the arrogant position suggesting that some DVC members are not capable of having an informed opinion due to their lack of "other experiences". For the purposes of this site, everyone is entitled to express their opinion whether you feel they are adequate or not. Since this is a DVC discussion board, it might even be worth considering that there are other sites where you can tout the places you feel are superior to the DVC HH resort. You might want to try TUG. This site is not really a HH timeshare site, it's a DVC discusison forum and DVC just happens to have a resort at that location.
While I do have an opinion of the Marriott resorts, this is not the appropriate place to discuss that. If I want to discuss the HH Marriott locations I would go to other websites as this is not the place to discuss them. In fact, I'll even suggest that Marriott discussion is probably off-topic for this forum.
I don't understand your insistence on arguing that it's superior to the DVC resort. BTW- can you call Mariott 7 months ahead and reserve a single night at WDW? I can with my HH ownership - or at least I have been able to every time I've tried over the last 10+ years. That's one of the benefits of DVC ownership.
As for offering DVC vs a Beach rental - it really doesn't matter since DVC is not and has never claimed to be a beach resort. It's really tiresome that you insist on trying to compare DVC to beach resorts- get over it - DVC is NOT a beach resort. There are LOTS of people who go to HH for activities other than the beach and there are LOTS of people who could care less about the beach or the resorts positioned there.
I will concede to you that if someone is looking for a summer beachfront location, the DVC HH resort is not the best place for them. In fact, I'll even suggest that if they are really looking for a beach location, HH may not be the best place for them at all - at ANY resort. I can think of many beachfront locations that I consider superior to HH. I do, however, enjoy the beach at HH and have spent many hours there over the years. The DVC HH resort Beach House is a great facility and the beach there is wonderful. I don't see the fact that you have to travel a little ways to get there from the resort as a negative at all although I understand that some require and demand that convenience.
If you're looking for a beach vacation in January, better drop HH from your plans entirely. However, HH can be delightful in January if you aren't locked into the need to be on the beach and I'd much rather be at the DVC HH resort than any other.