Wow, lots of replies here, awesome... Now that everyone is reading this thread, let me explain my EXTREME distaste with AT&T so you can see it from my little world.
The reason I would like everyone to grab their Iphones and toss them in the East River goes like this.
Since the break up of Ma Bell, the two leaders in cellular service, AT&T and Verizon have been concentrating on different areas. AT&T is like the federal government in that they concentrate solely on East Coast and West Coast and screw the "fly-over states" in between. They figure that everyone in between will just deal with the slim pickens that are handed to them as long as every New Yorker and Californian owns an IPHONE, they succeed. (for the purpose of this story, New York extends from Miami to Maine, thanks)
Verizon has been concentrating on it's network from coast to coast. Building more and more towers to compete with other providers, Verizon has successfully created the most dependable service for the "whole country". From Akron west to Salt Lake City and from Houston north to Minneapolis, Verizon covers 70% more area with 3G service.
Sure there are dropped calls anywhere you live, with any service provider, there are way too many geographical factors to be able to score one over the other, but the simple fact of tower placement and build frequency shows Verizon's dedication to "the whole country".
So why do I want the podcast crew to toss their Iphones? Here lies my other ethical problem with AT&T. This exclusivity clause with Apple basically ruins the chance for all us little people to have access to a "cool" product with "cool" service, and leaves it available only to those of you lucky to live in the coastal states that AT&T serves. I want a good product with good service at a good price and Verizon has shown they have the ability to do this much better than AT&T. (dont believe me, try taking your Iphone to an AT&T store and tell them you dropped it in the toilet and need a new one, Verizon would replace it on the spot.) The geniuses at APPLE will only stop dealing with AT&T if it becomes fiscally reasonable to switch to Verizon, or after continued network related embarassments at launch parties, but there are too many Kool Aid drinkers on the coasts buying and buying and buying.
Meanwhile, we sit in the nest and chirp as loud as we can on our Droids, hoping someday, maybe someday AT&T will build a tower closer to my house, and the house of the person I want to call.
OK, let the debate continue.