So many things and different atmospheres to choose from. You said no young children. Does that mean you have teen. My sons liked Marakesh (spelling) last time, but they were 18 and 21 at the time. So I think it was more the belly dancers then the food. Because of their ages we have steered towards buffetts. Between DH and my DS's and they always seem to bring a buddy along their appetites more then make up for the tiny amount DD15 eats. Boma is a good one. They also liked the seafood buffet at Cape May. We all liked the buffet at 1900 park fair. I know, I know you said not character meals. But honestley those stepsisters and Lady Tremaine are one of the best shows there. They spotted my sons and their friends ( they originally agreed to go for little sis), well that was all they needed. They couldn't decide which one they liked best so they started fighting over all of them. I laughed so hard I cried. The food was good to and a large variety. Another place that nobody mentions. Only those of us that stay at OKW seem to realize it is there is Olivia's. The menu is simple with a key west flair, make sure to get the key lime pie if you go.