~ SURVIVOR Samoa ~ Season 19 ~

[DisneyKing82]

So to clarify, your saying his behaviour is one of the worst of all the survivor's???

If you think he is a bad player, why? That is what I'm trying to understand.

I'll explain to you Happy's point of view. She's equating morality to being a good player. So only those people who can be completely honest and still win are the best players. Anyone who has to outwit and outlast their opponents are not worthy.

 

[tinatark]

Brett - so THAT'S who that was! DH and I were watching last night - at the end of TC, we both wondered aloud who the heck that guy was!

Talk about flying under the radar!

 

[muffyn]

ok, what happened to the cooked chicken?

they made a big point about her cooking it to smush.... but we never saw how it turned out.

or did I miss something??

 

[AlienBrain]

Who is everyone rooting for?

Me:

1) Natalie!!!!!!
2) Mick
3) Jaison
4) Shambo
5) Russell

 

[happygirl]

Mick
Jaison

 

[PatsMom]

I think at this point I am rooting for Natalie. I was trying to like Shambo but she is just too much of a flake for me. Jaison - something about him bugs me, can't put my finger on it. Its like he tends to just give up on things.

Russell has annoyed me from day one and I keep hoping he will be the next to go. But he keeps finding those darn idols!

 

[happygirl]

I'll explain to you Happy's point of view. She's equating morality to being a good player. So only those people who can be completely honest and still win are the best players. Anyone who has to outwit and outlast their opponents are not worthy.

Please don't speak for me ever again

 

[goofy's friends]

ok, what happened to the cooked chicken?

they made a big point about her cooking it to smush.... but we never saw how it turned out.

or did I miss something??

That's what DH and I were wondering!?!? I'm regrettably rooting for Russell. At this point, he's proven that he deserves to win. The one I'd really like to see win is Natalie.

 

[happygirl]

So to clarify, your saying his behaviour is one of the worst of all the survivor's???

If you think he is a bad player, why? That is what I'm trying to understand.

It was from the beginning when he dumped all there water out. He messed with there shoes and socks. I just prefer players who don't have to resort to being sneaky and deciitful. He has done nothing but lie to everyone around him. I'm really shocked he can keep all his stories straight

 

[happygirl]

ok, what happened to the cooked chicken?

they made a big point about her cooking it to smush.... but we never saw how it turned out.

or did I miss something??

I think that might have just been used to show the whole lets get Dave out thing

 

[declansdad]

Who is everyone rooting for?

Me:

1) Natalie!!!!!!
2) Mick
3) Jaison
4) Shambo
5) Russell

Russell
Natalie
Jaison

and that's it.

 

[declansdad]

It was from the beginning when he dumped all there water out. He messed with there shoes and socks. I just prefer players who don't have to resort to being sneaky and deciitful. He has done nothing but lie to everyone around him. I'm really shocked he can keep all his stories straight

So you don't like how he has played the game rather than his isn't a good player.

 

[happygirl]

So you don't like how he has played the game rather than his isn't a good player.

I don't think they way he has played can make him a good player

 

[happygirl]

I really can't figure out why people care If I like or dislike Russel

 

[declansdad]

I really can't figure out why people care If I like or dislike Russel

I don't care if you like him or not, he has been pretty hard to like. However, you can separate whether you respect someone from how good they are at something. The strategy that he has used has been very good. He quickly adapts and outplays his competitors. That has got nothing to do with his behaviour.

 

[4greatboys]

1--Russell
2--Natalie

then Mick or Jaison

 

[4greatboys]

I really can't figure out why people care If I like or dislike Russel

I don't think anyone cares if you like Russell or not. But I think it's silly to say he is not a good player. The difference being good does not = nice.

 

[PatsMom]

I don't think anyone cares if you like Russell or not. But I think it's silly to say he is not a good player. The difference being good does not = nice.

I've got to agree with this. Russell is certainly not nice - if I were going to buy him a T shirt it would say something like "Does not play well with others". But I don't think that makes him a bad player. I don't want him to win because I find him obnoxious but I have to admit he has played a good game if you look at it from the standpoint of Outwitting and Outlasting!

 

[wdhinn89]

Anyone thinking Brett has a chance to win this? Possibly the most boring Survivor player in history but doing an amazing job of staying under the radar.

I have been telling my husband this for weeks. I think he is going to fly under the radar and win. Personally, I like Natalie She has really surprised me at how she has played the game. She was very surprising last night.

I don't care if you like him or not, he has been pretty hard to like. However, you can separate whether you respect someone from how good they are at something. The strategy that he has used has been very good. He quickly adapts and outplays his competitors. That has got nothing to do with his behaviour.

Give it a rest already!!!

 

[allie_to_you]

I hated Russell in the early weeks of this season...so much that I just couldn't wait for them to vote him off, but now, I hope he wins. Sure, he's a coniving and lies behind everyone's back, but it's almost to the point that it's funny because everyone else is stupid enough to fall for his junk and the fact that he has found all the idols is just hilarious to me.