I can't compare the two, but I can tell you that Silver Lake is wonderful. We've stayed their twice, once renting and once swapping in with RCI and loved it both times. We had the 2 bedroom unit that sleeps 8/8 and it was HUGE!! I use a wheelchair and had tons of room to get around. We will actually be staying there for part of our June trip this year. Have fun.
Lisa
Tiger Fan aka The Great Tiger