No sure about other styles, but these are the ones I love. http://www.amazon.com/Skechers-Womens-Go-Walk-Slip-On/dp/B005GI8UZ8 . I wear them without socks (I'm a sock hater), but you could wear them with a thin sock.
I would go with Orthaheels. I asked my local running store for flip flop recommendations and they suggested these. They have changed my life!
Those sound good! Do you buy them online?
I got them at Fleet Feet, but I know you can get them on Zappos.
jojomojo said:Just got back, thought I'd update
....I got a blister on my broken toe from buddy taping! Not fun....Guess I just need to have two pairs (make sure they are always dry, might have been the problem), or wear socks.
Two things. First, did you put cotton between your toes before taping the, together?
Fit flops!! They are super comfy!!