Once again a category is missing. How about I like both equally? My first experience with the "simulator" style ride was Body Wars. I thought it was amazing. When I got to do Star Tours, I was equally impressed. Both of them were pretty tame compared to Universals Back to the Future ride and I liked that one as well.
I agree that it is yesterdays technology but it is old only to those of us that have seen it before. First time riders, I think, can still be impressed by them. I have been fortunate that I never have any motion sickness