We booked a crown loft gty and got upgraded to a sky loft suite when they assigned our room a couple weeks before the cruise. The genie took care of everything. Sent us an email with a iterinary of all the shows and restaurants he had set up. We could change anything we wanted. We only ate at specialty dining or the coastal kitchen. He would save the best seats at all the shows and we just had to be there 15 min before. Anything we wanted in the mini bar was there was us. Also got of few surprises like a anniversary cake, and chocolate covered strawberries in the room.
We booked an over the water cabana thru the genie. He escorted us off the ship to the end of dock where a golf cart took us the rest of way even though it was that far to the beach.
We enjoyed star class and all the perks that came with it. It would probably depend on the cost if we would do it again. We got an amazing price since we got a crown loft for the sky loft price. I'm sure we would of been happy with sky class though.