we did this show 2 years ago and loved it so much we are doing it again on our upcoming trip. i have been to a number of luaus and although this is not a conventional luau, the firedancer and other dancers were great. my dh and ds loved the show and the food, as did i. i had booked this the first day i could and chose category 1 seating and we were lucky enough to get front center seats, best in the house. this definitely made the experience better and i would recommend going for the best seats if you can because it is more enjoyable. i can't comment on hoop de doo, but for us, the luau type of food and entertainment is more our style than the country style food and review. that being said, everyone always loves the hoop dee doo . the reviews are very favorable. sooo, count this as one vote for spirit of aloha. ( we are also trying ohana this time, having loved kona.) i guess we just love the food at the poly, altho we aren't staying there! good luck with your decision