We did both restaurants in November. It is kind of like comparing apples to oranges. Food wise, The Wave was the best food we had the entire vacation. It was a nice romantic quiet meal. It was like a secret getaway in the hustle and bustle. Spice Road was good food, the best service we had, and we got to watch Illuminations while we ate. However, it was crowded and loud. So, I would say if you want a quiet tasty meal, The Wave. If you want good food in an upbeat atmosphere, Spice Road.