So what is wrong with Stove-Top?

homemade or stovetop brand makes no difference to me so long as it's not cooked inside the turkey.

I like my stuffing crisped on the top and not saturated with (albeit washed out and eventuraly 'cooked') raw poultry juices.


as a kid I never ate stuffing b/c mom included the 'innards' BLECH! as an adult I tried it without and enjoyed it, but still I prefer stuffing cooked outside the bird with a crisp topping.

I use stovetop but doctor it-instead of water I use sodium free chicken broth. I add sauted celery, chopped pecans and some craisins (the puff up and add a nice tang).


as for the sodium-I use next to none in cooking anything else, and my kids have never known the concept of having a salt shaker on the dinner table so I figure it balances out.


as for what goes inside our bird-I take a couple of oranges and cut them in half. I squeeze the juice onto to the top of bird before I season it (I see no reason to oil it, there's enough fat in the skin to suffice). I put the rest of the oranges (peel and all) inside the bird. it heats and steams the inside so I get even cooking.
 
To be fair, with cilantro, studies have shown that people can have a genetic predisposition that makes cilantro taste like soap. It's not their fault. ;)
WHAT? Thats the biggest load of poo poo I've ever heard. :lmao:

I have a genetic predisposition to not like green beans. ;)
 

Interesting. Learn something new every day.

I happen to LOVE it. Makes food taste fresh and delicious.

I take it you don't like salsa or guacamole? :confused3

Most times in salsa or guac it's chopped up small enough that you don't get a big taste of it. If there's too much, and the whole dish tastes like it, then no I don't like it. But mostly it's when there are whole leaves that it's a problem... yuck!
 
Most times in salsa or guac it's chopped up small enough that you don't get a big taste of it. If there's too much, and the whole dish tastes like it, then no I don't like it. But mostly it's when there are whole leaves that it's a problem... yuck!

so do you also avoid foods with coriander since they are from the same plant?
 
We will use it for turkey day but We will be adding veggies to it we just love the cornbread stuffing they make
 
Hey! If I come to your house for dinner and you serve stovetop, I'll simply pass on the stuffing. Then, I'll come home and make some real stuffing. Gotta have the big pieces of soft bread with large oniion pieces, great sage and good chicken stock. I like it cooked with a crunchy top, because it has carmelized and formed a crust. Stovetop is too dry for me. I made it once and used twice the liquid. Then I chopped some onions and dried sage into it and it was passable. I actually soaked the bread cubes for a long while. It's a shortcut. I eat bread very rarely because of the carbs,so it's got to be fabulous to make it worth it. And Happy Thanksgiving!!!
 
We'll be having Stove Top tomorrow. My family likes it better than "real" stuffing.:confused3

My kids like Stove Top better too! (I use chicken broth instead of water.) But they've had stuffing so many ways they always want "moms" which is, yikes, Stove Top! :rotfl:

One time we went to my parents house for Thanksgiving and my mom added mushrooms to the stuffing. I literally saw my son's face go from smile to frown the minute he noticed the mushrooms and didn't eat the stuffing. ;)
 
If I'm making a turkey, I want old fashioned bread stuffing cooked inside the bird. I make it the way my mom did, with butter-sauteed onions and celery, lots of sage/poultry seasoning, home-cut and toasted bread cubes, either chicken stock or turkey stock, and an egg. This only happens on Thanksgiving, and only when we eat at home (we are usually invited to our friends' home). Any other day of the year, if we are eating stuffing, it's Stove Top. We don't have stuffing, per se, as a side dish very often, but I will use it on top of pork chops or chicken breasts that I am baking in the oven. It gets crunchy on top, stays soft underneath, and flavors the meat nicely. Sometimes I'll make the Stove Top by first sautéing some celery and onion, adding the stuffing mix, and then using chicken stock, but that gets salty if I don't have sodium-free stock on hand (which is usually the case), and it seems like a lot of fuss and bother for a "convenience" food!

As much as I like unique, interesting foods, I am not a fan of "fussy" stuffing. I'll eat it, but I am not crazy about stuffing with cornbread, pecans, cranberries, rice, etc. Interestingly, the only non-traditional stuffing I ever enjoyed was one that my chef-BIL made, with oysters in it. I adore oysters, and he made an amazing stuffing, baked outside the turkey. Alas… that was the year that food poisoning made its rounds, only visiting those of us who ate the oyster stuffing… :sick: :eek:
 
I've now read three comments here insulting Stove-Top stuffing.


I happen to really like it much more than any other home-made stuffing.

Nothing, I like all kinds of stuffing.

However on Thanksgiving I make "Grandma's Sausage Stuffing". It is "tradition".

It is made the "fresh turkey stock" which makes it so yummy. It just has a "dash" of sausage in it now so it flavors the stuffing. Yep, was sampling yesterday as I made it. :rolleyes1
 
The problem is that it is Thanksgiving!

Just as I would not serve instant potatoes from a box, I would not serve stove top today.
 
I like Stove Top well enough. But its not anywhere close to what we serve on Thanksgiving. Even the cornbread stuffing is anything like the cornbread dressing we make,
 
I don't think there's anything wrong with it. We have it a few times a year if we need something quick to make for dinner. Stove Top has a weird aftertaste to me, and I prefer making homemade stuffing if I have the time.
 
I usually have a box of stove top in the pantry for a quick side dish. I don't really like it though. It has an odd cardboard taste to me. We are trying to eat less processed foods and as others have said, it is full of sodium. I love a fresh homemade stuffing. It's like eating fresh carrots instead of canned. Fresh is always better, but the canned are okay in a pinch.
 
Properly made stuffing from a good cook will blow the doors off of Stove Glop easily.

I agree! :thumbsup2

Stove Top is "okay" for a quick dinner, but for Thanksgiving I prefer homemade. My DMIL shared her recipe for stuffing/dressing with me and I've made it several times. It's wonderful!!
 
And those people would be wrong. Stuffing and dressing are interchangeable terms and the use of one or the other has absolutely nothing to do with where the mixture is cooked. As for me, I'm not the biggest fan of stove glop. 400 mg of sodium in a dinky little 1/2 cup's worth (prepared) is very high. Properly made stuffing from a good cook will blow the doors off of Stove Glop easily.


:thumbsup2 Especially with mushrooms, celery, onions!
The aroma alone is intoxicating. I'm requested to bring a crock pot full to our annual New Year's Day pot luck dinners!
We hold it in a church hall b/c we are 125+ immediate family!

Gobble, Gobble (Turkey icon) ;)
 
The problem is that it is Thanksgiving!

Not everyone thinks Thanksgiving is all that.


Just as I would not serve instant potatoes from a box, I would not serve stove top today.

If instant potatoes is what my family likes then that is what I would make and serve. My family likes Stove Top so that is what I make and serve.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom