I've eaten there twice. Once outside and once inside. I loved eating outside as it was christmastime and I loved looking at all of the decorations. As far as food goes, I thought it was good both times but nothing to write home about. Why do you want to go there?
This is one of my favorite places to eat. I do not go there for spaghetti and meatballs, which I have heard isn't that good. Their NY Strip is wonderful as is this Eggplant stuff. If you haven't check out allearsnet.com, go there to take a look at the menu. Then you will know if there is something that you would even order. Hope you have a great time there!!!
I personally would do California Grill for my birthday because that is my favorite restaurant. But since that is not on your list, I will recommend Tony's or the San Angel Inn because they are must-do's for us also!
I think Tony's is very good, I've eaten there twice and liked it both times. I got the spaghetti and meatballs (sub spaghetti for penne pasta). The service was great both times, too!! But for my birthday dinner, I would choose Le Cellier!! It is my personal favorite.
I know a lot of people aren't crazy about Tony's, but I just don't get it. We ate there on a whim on the last day of our last trip. The whole family loved it. I'd say go for it!
We visit it every time we go to WDW. It is the only restaurant we never miss. I think it'd be great for a b-day lunch! They really have wonderful pizza. Their appetizers are great as well. I say go for it!
Four years ago, my DH and I went there to celebrate his BDay for lunch, and I had mentioned it when making my PS...IT WAS WONDERFUL! DH loved it so much...they decorated his table, they all walked by(we were outside) and wished him a HB, and then the Dapper-Dans and a Dixieland band came inside and sang/played to/for him! I don't know how they did it...but they did! The food was great, and has been, as we go back there every time we are at WDW. Do Tony's...you'll love it!