We had dinner at Boatwrights last year, and we really enjoyed it! Our food was very good, and our server was excellent. We're planning to go again on our trip this year, and I hope we don't have a bad experience like some others here have had.
We ate there in October and it was just ok. I can't even remember what I ate but my husband had ribs and he thought the ones at the Hoopty Doo Review(? is that the name of it?) where way better. I know the kids really liked the huge sundae they got for dessert, but I don't think we'd bother eating there again.
We loved the dinner and breakfast there (banana stuffed french toast ) The dinner is especially nice when coupled with the boat ride to Downtown Disney that they offer. Seeing the lights as you approach in the boat was beautiful! I guess they are doing horse and carriage rides now also.