We really enjoy Shutter's!!! (Family has been twice--DH 4 times) Try the island wings (if you like SPICEY) and the salad. The kid's sandcastle dessert is darling! It's a very casual and charming place. Yum!
We have not been to Maya's in years. We were not impressed. I know the menu has changed since we have been there, though. Now, we do enjoy Maya for breakfast. Very good breakfast burritos!