I like the one with Santa, did you have that done at Camp Snoopy? It is a little bright, though. I think either are cute. I like less then perfect Christmas pictures because it shows the kids in their true life. We sent one card several years ago where DS10 had this HUGE smile, DS13 had a MAJOR pout going and DD was looking off into the distance. All totally their personalities. DH has that one on his desk at work.