Shakes at 50s PTC

[TheBluthCompany]

Does anyone have a list of the flavors of shakes at 50s PTC? I remember reading on here that they make excellent milk shakes and have some pretty unique flavors

 

[ohiodisneydad2]

Does anyone have a list of the flavors of shakes at 50s PTC? I remember reading on here that they make excellent milk shakes and have some pretty unique flavors

I know of two. The peanut butter cup which I've had and tastes just like a Reese Cup. There's also a Peanut Butter and Jelly.

 

[TheBluthCompany]

That peanut butter and jelly shake sounds really interesting! Is is peanut butter ice cream mixed with grape or strawberry flavoring?

 

[jess20k]

I don't know all of the flavors they offer, but I can tell you the Peanut Butter and Jelly Shake is awesome! It sounds gross, but it is so good. It does not taste like jelly at all..lol. Anyway, I am one that usually does not get milk shakes, but when my DS ordered it and I had a taste, I was hooked!

 

[Princess Polamalu]

Just like a Resse Cup?? Oh my I may have to have one of those this spring. Sounds yummy.

 

[squirrel]

The PB & J is so good! I don't know what kind of jelly they use but you hardly taste it.

 

[TheDisneyGirl02]

That peanut butter and jelly shake sounds really interesting! Is is peanut butter ice cream mixed with grape or strawberry flavoring?

I can't go to Prime Time without getting a PBJ milk shake! I've had it at other places, but nobody can make it like Prime Time!

 

[MickeyEars]

I've definitely got to try this when we dine there May 31st. I keep reading about the peanut butter and jelly shake but we've never tried it. Can you get it as your dessert on the dining plan?

Thanks!
Carla

 

[honeydiane1953]

Well peanut butter and jelly. Folks go on and on for me it just sounds awful. But I haven't tried it and prob never will try it.

 

[TheDisneyGirl02]

I've definitely got to try this when we dine there May 31st. I keep reading about the peanut butter and jelly shake but we've never tried it. Can you get it as your dessert on the dining plan?

Thanks!
Carla

The last time I did the DDP, I believe we were able to get the shake as a drink. I ordered that and water. We still got dessert too.

 

[ThanksForNoticingMe]

How large are the shakes? Are they big enough for two or three people to share?

 

[ohiodisneydad2]

How large are the shakes? Are they big enough for two or three people to share?

They are decent sized plus they bring you the metal shake cup that has the leftover that wouldn't fit in your glass. I'd say two people could share. Once you find out how good the shakes are, you'll have a hard time letting a third person in the mix.

I really wanted to try the PB & J shake but somehow I wound up with the peanut butter cup one. I guess it's not "somehow"...quite frankly the staff psychs you out! You are so afraid to make a mistake and get called on the carpet, in a fun way.

One young girl had to stand up and sing I'm a little tea pot because she was texting during dinner. I had to clean up the table since my wife took all three of my girls to the bathroom w/o asking for permission. The whole place is awesome. Sorry, kinda got off topic....BUT GET A SHAKE WHILE YOU'RE THERE!