The first party was very much uncharacteristically crowded, but that wasn't due to the number of tickets sold (though the party did sell out); Disney did a horrible job of having those without tickets leave the park. For the first party we didn't recall any announcements of the park closing for the event (though we could have missed it) nor did we see anyone looking for those without bracelets. Normally you can't get into certain areas without someone checking for a bracelet. It was so crowded that night that we actually left much earlier than we normally would have. But, all in all, we still had a good time.
The second party was quite a bit better; it was still busy but nothing like the first one.
I do want to correct my above post, the first Party in 2014 was Sept 1... not sure how I missed that. So maybe we will get lucky.
The alternative means of keeping up with demand would be to close MK at 7PM more frequently within a smaller window. I can't fathom that idea would fly.
1) They can still charge for the events and get gate fees twice on party days.
2) Halloween doesn't have the same pre-existing guest crush as Christmas/New Years.
If they were to add the Halloween stuff gratis, you'd have more people in the parks, and Disney wouldn't get to double-dip any of them.
The alternative means of keeping up with demand would be to close MK at 7PM more frequently within a smaller window. I can't fathom that idea would fly.
I can only speak to my experience, but when I travel to MK during either the Halloween or Christmas stretches, I always get a handful of midnight + days. If I were presented with majority 7PM closures, I think I would forgo traveling in that window. I speculate that too many people would feel the same for WDW not to be impacted by that viewpoint. 3-4 7PM closures each week is about all the system can bear, IMHO.
Actually, in 2014, the first party was Sepember 1.
Last year, there were early September 7pm closures on the schedule that later switched to normal non party days. Hopefully they will announce the dates and the new costume rules this week. Last year, dates were released on Feb 25, with tickets going on sale April 8.