As a follow up to my post I had someone purchase it a little while ago on ebay. I was thrilled, then I saw he is new, has only 3 feedbacks and has won thousands of dollars in gift cards in the past week. I emailed him and told him I would probably cancel the transaction since something doesn't sit right with me. He said no problem, refund me immediately. He didn't even try to convince me otherwise! I told him I would refund him when he approved the cancellation of transaction through ebay so I don't get charged the fees.
I was going to send it with delivery confirmation and signature required, but I'm not even sure how you prove you mailed a gift card with xxxx dollars when the buyer could say it has something else on it and then I risk a chargeback. I really hope his other sellers don't get screwed!!