Here is my 2 cents:
ON SITE-
Sonya's & Shutters are both outstanding. Sonya's is more formal, however they share the same kitchen so the menus are similar. In fact, they can get anything from the others menu if you ask nice. I had a great poched flounder (I think that was the fish) at Sonya's, and would highly recommend it.
Sonya's expensive, Shutters moderately expensive.
OFF SITE-
We have ate at The Ocean Grill, and The Black Pearl (Riverside- I think there is another). Ocen Grill was outstanding. The shrimp cocktail was to die for, but I suggest ordering a side of horseradish to spice up the sauce. It is a very busy restaurant, so be prepared to wait in the bar area for an hour or more.
The Black Pearl (Riverside) was okay, but I would not return. It seemed a little 'odd' in there. I can't quite put my finger on it. Although food and service were adequate, something did not sit right. Some locals said that it changed owners within the past couple of years, and it has gone downhill.
Ocean Grill expensive, The Black Pearl moderately expensive.
Sonya's, Shutters, and The Ocean Grill are all great places, and I will return to all of them!
Enjoy your trip!
