chartle
DIS Legend
- Joined
- Jul 10, 2008
- Messages
- 16,340
OK. As long as there is no mayo involved. I hate mayo.
Miracle Whip OK
OK. As long as there is no mayo involved. I hate mayo.
I agree with you.The Government should have been more concerned about the "deregulation" of the banks/loaning agencies that nearly caused the total collapse of our economy-instead of "regulating"wether,and how long,we should be able to take our children out of school for a family vacation!I just have to through my two cents in here.
Unfortunately this subject has nothing to do with education and everything to do with politics. The government in recent history has felt the need to tell us how we should raise or children and they are putting regulations to do so in the schools systems. They don't think us average Americans know how to properly raise our children, so they will regulate us for our own good....
Politicians wonder why more and more parents are home schooling. They can't figure out that we are sick of them deciding what is best for our OWN families. Get a hint Government, we don't need you telling us if we can take OUR children out to go on a family vacation. Regulation overload!!
Lucky as of now, there is no issue with this where I live. The moment I do my kids will not be attending the public school system.
DW,and myself are healthcare workers-basically the same deal.By the way,where are you?We're in LaPlace!My family and I including my DS9 will be going to WDW next week. He will miss three days. I am a RN and due to the type of nursing I can not take off and go on vacations especially at holiday times. Holidays and the weeks surrounding them are the times we are not allowed under any circumstances to be allowed off. Summer is also busiest since kids are all out of school.
I send the school a note stating the dates DS will be absent, but I STILL get calls asking me if I knew my son was absent on each daywhile IN Disney!! I even remind them I sent a note and spoke with the teacher.this does NOT mean the absences will be excused though. The teachers allow work and tests missed to be made up. Tests will be made up instead of going to recess. DS happily does so to get to go to WDW.
Where we are, the school limits absences to 10 unexcused a school year and once you reach 7 unexcused absences the district attorney calls and sends you a letter. Almost an investigation. This seems a bit exaggerate, but i think its mostly for those who keep kids out all the time.
I have nothing to hide. I teach my kids to be honest. We are going to WDW now because my job as a nurse doesnt allow for it during holiday periods or summers bc that is when it is busiest at my job. He will make up the work at home with the guidance and help of my husband and I. Ill gladly take the responsibility for taking him out and making up the work, just excuse the absences. He never misses otherwise thankfully!! I have no problem with this but trust me, it does not happen often!! Its the whole "one bad apple ruins it for the bunch".
Btw, i am surprised more healthcare workers have not chimed in on this.![]()
Dear School,
A. I am taking them out because they are my kids and I choose to.
B. My taxes pay your salary so you answer to me, I don't answer to you.
That will be all![]()
Dear School,
A. I am taking them out because they are my kids and I choose to.
B. My taxes pay your salary so you answer to me, I don't answer to you.
That will be all![]()
We're heading to WDW for Thanksgiving and this is the first time, since kindergarten, that I'll be taking my kids out of school (they're now in high school and middle school). I'm dreading writing that letter and hoping that all of their teachers will be on board and supply them with homework/lessons that need to be completed. My plan is to just tell them that we are spending Thanksgiving with family out of state........after all, Mickey, Minnie and the rest of the gang are family, aren't they?![]()
Ever since NCLB, teachers hav become babysitters who teach a standardized test.
How about, "Dear School Administrators,
We are taking our kids out of school for ____ days from ___ (Month) to ____ (Month) so that the family can enjoy lower crowds and less expensive lodging at Walt Disney World, in Florida. The educational lessons of this family vacation will include:
1) economics - the importance of maximizing savings on family vacations
2) geography - the location, weather, and municipal infrastructure of Orlando, Florida
3) math - how quickly costs can add up for food, lodging and souvenirs
4) sociology - the diverse nature of people who attend theme parks
5) psychology - methods used by Disney to induce higher spending in their theme parks
6) English - grammatically correct signs and warnings on thrill rides
7) history - many Disney rides are based on myths and legends, and several are based on bona fide historical American artifacts and personalities
8) physics - actually experiencing positive and negative G-forces on several thrill rides
9) science - discovering the effects of dehydration and lack of sleep
10) foreign languages - hearing several languages in use by actual foreigners
11) biology - seeing, smelling, and possibly depositing stomach contents on the sidewalk after thrill rides
12) engineering - viewing and actually riding highly engineered thrill rides
13) astrology - examining and describing stars seen on the "Hollywood Walk of Fame" in DHS
14) art - experiencing actual animation instruction and getting a back-lot view of motion picture production
15) phys ed - walking approximately seven miles per day.
I hope you agree that, based on this ___ week visit, my children should be awarded a bachelor's degree in General Studies from the nearest state college. If that is not possible, please provide instructions on how my children can complete any additional requirements of their regularly scheduled classes (as if their classes could possibly cover anything remotely as comprehensive as this vacation will expose them to!).
Very truly yours,
Mrs X"
That should get the ball rolling for you...
To Whom It Concerns,
ChildOMine will not be in school from Date to date.
Sincerely,
Mother of Child
Really, that's all I ever gave a school. Not their business. I decided if it was reasonable for my child to skip school, I did not need permission or validation. Unless a child is old enough to need buy in from the teachers to preserve a grade, I see no reason to give details.
DW,and myself are healthcare workers-basically the same deal.By the way,where are you?We're in LaPlace!![]()
That's fine, as long as you are prepared to accept the consequences of the absences. Schools have the right (by law) to set attendance guidelines and the consequences of unexcused absences, like zeros or citations. These rules should be clearly spelled out in the parent handbook. When you sign your child up for public school, you are agreeing to that district's policies, including attendance. If you don't like the policies, you are free to seek other options.
I agree with you.The Government should have been more concerned about the "deregulation" of the banks/loaning agencies that nearly caused the total collapse of our economy-instead of "regulating"wether,and how long,we should be able to take our children out of school for a family vacation!I do however understand that it is each parents duty to do what is in the best interest of THEIR children;everyones situation/children are different-some can miss school,and be able to do well,and others don't do well,even when attending school without missing a single day-go figure?
We plan on taking our DD's out for 5 days-just like last year,and will writea basic letter informing them of their absence.They did'nt give us any problem,but we did receive a letter from the "truancy police".I was pepared to defend our decision,but never had to-they never said or did anything.
The only problem in our situation is that the max days that can be missed is 11-excused or unexcused;which to me is utterly ridiculous!!!
![]()
As a parent of a 38 y/o, a 35 y/o and an almost 18 y/o, I also spend every day teaching. But, that isn't going to amount to a hill of beans when my 18 y/o can't figure out the stuff that was covered in her Algebra ll class while she was in WDW.
Here's the thing. Every parent should be able to decide when they vacation as a family. And they should be able to decide if missing school is going to be an issue for their kids. Most school systems have either a handbook or other guidelines that outline what is expected. School systems differ....so while one parent may 'have' to have a reason to take their child out of school for vacation, another parent at a different school may not have to.
My issue??? The prevailing mentality that 'my family deserves to vacation whenever we want. Our kids learn all sorts of great stuff at WDW so they aren't really missing that much by not being in school. And we ask for all their assignments before we leave anyway, It's our right to get those homework assignments early.'
Just drives me nutty. THe entire holier than thou attitude here is nuts. I don't particularly care if you take your kids out of school. As long as you are knowledgable about your particular school districts are, and you are within those guidelines, fine, have a ball.
It's all about choices...we all make choices, and we have to live with the ramifications of those choices.
This is a great approach. I'm going to ask my kid's teacher to come over and do the laundry. I pay her salary, after all!
What do you imagine the consequences of the OP pulling her kid out for two half days will be? I'm guessing it will be right about what they were every time I pulled my kid out- being not a single thing.![]()
In some districts, and possibly most of them, this is not true---not if the absence is unexcused. In almost any district, it needn't be done in advance if doing so is an unreasonable burden (i.e. the assignment is not ready yet).
I love WDW. I really do. I love taking my kids to WDW. I love doing that when there aren't tons of other people doing that.
But, lets be honest here: it's vacation, not a semester abroad. Are there "learning opportunities"? Sure. Is it "an educational trip"? I think if we looked hard in the mirror, we'd agree that no, it is not. Now, some teachers/administrators might be willing to call it educational in a wink-wink nudge-nudge sort of way to work within the bounds of a district's (or state's) enrollment policy, but that's a different question.
I have taken my DS out of school for a few days for several WDW vacations. I know all about the controversy on the DISBoards that this awakens, but I still feel that the time spent together as a family for just a few days has a far greater impact on my son than a few days in school. We are going again in October and he will miss 4 days of school as an 8th grader. He is rarely sick, so he hardly ever misses any other school days. I figure this will be our last chance to visit WDW during the slower times, since he will be in high school next year, but I have never regretted taking him out of school for a few days during his elementary and middle school years. The family bonding time has been well worth the time needed to catch up in school.Our district teachers have been nothing less than supportive and understanding.