We've had Safeco for our home insurance for years. They are a little higher than other companies I think, but they are very responsive, and their customer service is great. We had a pipe burst one February when we were in Mexico. I think it had just happened a little before we got home at 2:00 am, but we called Safeco, and someone came out the next day, and they had ServePro here with their fans and stuff later that day I think.
We've gotten cheaper quotes, but we choose to stay with them. However, I can't speak to Auto insurance with them.