I’ve read every post in this thread from day one and something is not clear to me:
How many people each day WANT to join a BG but are unable to get a BG?
Almost everyone here seems to end up getting a BG when they try, even with the fluctuations in the specifics (park opening time, BG opening time, etc).
Every argument about what system is “fair” (mine included) relies on some hypothetical guests that wanted to join a BG, but couldn’t.
But who are those people? They don’t seem to be here. At least there are way fewer of them than people who are successfully joining BGs.
I know the “average guest” is not the same as the average DIS user. But I’m really curious about all those other people. How many are actually arriving at the park intending to join a BG to ride RotR and don’t get to?
You can’t assume everyone who goes to the park intends to ride RotR because some aren’t interested, and some might just decide to skip it until a future trip.