Argh. This has to be the worst and weirdest decision the View could have possibly made. I fear that it will make the View the loudest and most opinionated show on TV.
Even though I disagree with her on basically everything, I feel really sorry for Joy in this decision. She is decidedly the 'comedian' on the show, and Rosie will be seen as competition. If you think about it, everyone on the show holds some demographic and this is going to disrupt the balance of the show, IMO. Joy and Rosie will be constantly trying to 'one up' each other and it will spin out of control. Mark my words, Joy will be the next to go.
Meredith was always the one to reign in the others, and with her gone it's going to be a free-for-all. They should have picked another newsy anchor woman type as a replacement.