But, in a nutshell, those that do rope drop are most often doing it for the reduced lines and crowds not for the show (generalizing here).
ETA: Special things have happend to us being at RD that have been amazing for my daughter. Family of the day, first ride on EE so getting a special button, being first at AK and my DD got to roll the scroll for the times board with Mickey and get special seats for FotLK, first ride on Dumbo so she got to ride w/Stitch, into Fantasyland early so getting to play ring around the rosie with Minnie and Daisy, riding on ToT twice in a row w/no waits right away. If you don't call that enjoying the atmosphere, I'm not sure what is!!!