I would recommend Victoria and Albert's and the California Grill as our two top choices. However, this year, for our 35th anniversary (next Monday) we are doing the private dining at the Grand Floridian...I hadn't heard of this before we started planning this trip, but it sounded like an "over the top" experience we haven't had before so we decided to go for it. You basically get to tell them what your food preferences are and they suggest a menu for your approval; it's served on a private balcony in the GF with a view of the MK fireworks over dessert and served by your own personal butler...
To give you an idea of how it works, here's the confirmation email I got:
This is to confirm your Intimate Dinner on (date). Your butler will meet your party at our Grand Piano located in our main lobby at 6:30 pm. Please review the menu that our chef has created and let me know if you have any questions. The cost of your Intimate Dinner is $85.00 per person, plus 6.5% tax, 18% gratuity and $75.00 butler fee.
French Onion Soup
Caesar Salad with Focaccia Breadstick
Filet of Beef accompanied by a Crab Cake, served with Mushroom Ragout,
Haricot Verts (for her) and Grilled Asparagus (for him) with a Roasted Garlic Au Jus
Water is included. Other beverages are additional.
Over our "Wishes" fireworks a special dessert will be served.
I think it will be memorable! If you want more information on how to set it up, PM me.
Enjoy your vacation!!!