Reviews of Disney Resort Rooms

Status
Not open for further replies.
http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=3231284

I know that I should just let this thread die, but I couldn't help myself. :rolleyes1

Let's look deeper at the rankings that you quote. First, the Disney hotels were not ranked in the best hotels in the USA. They weren't even close. Here was a list of the top 169 hotels in the USA.

http://travel.usnews.com/features/2014-Best-Hotels-in-the-USA-Winners/

Furthermore, the list that everyone has been pointing too with the Disney Resorts on them was just a list of the Best Orlando-Walt Disney World Hotels that were 4 or 5 stars. The hotels had to be classified as a 4 or 5 star hotel to be even be ranked. After meeting that criteria, that left only 43 hotels in the Orlando-Walt Disney World area for USA news to judge/rank. All the hotels were ranked on the list from 1- 43. Given that Disney has multiple hotels/resorts, one would hope that just by their numbers, they would have some that would make the list higher up. Disney has 14 hotel/resorts out of the 43 hotels that met the 4 star criteria. (33% of the pool )

Some of the Resorts everyone on here claim to be the best were near the bottom of the list.

#20 out of 43 - Disney's Animal Kindgom Kidani Villas
#28 out of 43 - The Poly Resort
#29 out of 43 - Disney Beach Club Villas
#31 out of 43 - Villas at Disney Wilderness Lodge
#34 out of 43 - Disney's Contemporary Resort
#37 out of 43 - Disney's Swan and Dolphin
Bay Lake Tower didn't even make the rankings because it was classified as a 3.5 star resort.

Half of the Disney's hotels/resorts were near the bottom of the rankings/list for the Orlando market.

:wave2:
 
I would not be looking at the villas myself (although I am a happy owner), they are just not generally maintained or refurbished like the cash resorts. Which I am good with since I would be paying for that.

Hotels 7-12 are Disney resorts. Seems pretty good to me. Since staying at the Ritz, the Waldorf or even the Peabody and the like are not going to happen when I go to WDW, those really aren't relevant to me. And comparing them to all the hotels in the country, while it might help you determine what to expect compared to other places you've been or know about, doesn't really have any bearing if you're comparing Orlando hotels, does it? You only care about what's in Orlando.
 
Let's look deeper at the rankings that you quote. First, the Disney hotels were not ranked in the best hotels in the USA. They weren't even close. Here was a list of the top 169 hotels in the USA.

I'm confused...I thought the original question was specifically about the WDW resorts. When did the top hotels in the rest of the USA enter into it?
 

I am puzzled why someone would bother to join a group like this and point out these bad reviews and not let it drop almost like a starved rabid dog holding on to a bone, or is this just to spoil it for those with upcoming trips, must be real satisfying!
 
Talk about not letting it drop, can someone throw a bone instead! Thanks for peeing on my excitement for my upcoming trip. Got any cheerful stroke or heart attack reviews to cheer us up with whilst your at it.
 
Just ignore the haters. I can assure you that every Disney resort, regardless of the going rate per night, positively oozes magic and fairies. In fact, they're the cleanest and most technologically advanced rooms on the planet. The staff is the best-looking in the industry and nothing bad happens there. Ever.

Remember, Fantasyland is but one part of the WDW experience, not the entirety.
 
Hi OP - I haven't read this whole thread, but I can imagine there are a lot of strong opinions. I just wanted to chime in and say that we've been to Disney 20+ times in the last 10 years and have stayed in almost every deluxe resort and a couple moderates. No doubt with that many trips we're bound to experience some negatives along the way -- but it's always easy enough to simply report those issues to housekeeping or management for a resolution. One time we had to switch rooms which was a huge inconvenience, but we were happy that the resort resolved the issue for us. Honestly, there will always be problems at any vacation destination at any given time. We keep going back to Disney because it's the perfect family trip for us.:thumbsup2
 
I'm amazed to see this thread still going.

The OP has decided not to stay on site because of reviews of resorts she's never been to. It's a done deal; she's not going there, based on those reviews. That's great; each of us does what we think is best for our families.

Yet she continues to respond to positive reviews of those same resorts, contradicting the actual first hand experiences of posters with reviews from anonymous sources. For resorts she's not considering. And that she has never been to.

I can't imagine the logic. Once you've made your decision, why on earth would you continue an argument about the choices you've decided against? Why not move on with your trip planning, with your family, with your job, with other more important things-- with life? Why continue to argue just for the sake of arguing, particularly if what you're bringing to the "discussion" is someone else's experience and not your own.

It just makes no sense to me. Not for an adult with no other agenda. The only logical conclusion is that the OP is not an adult without an agenda. Either he/she is a child with too much time on his/her hands, or there's something else going on. But these are not the actions of an adult trying to discern the best place for her family to stay on vacation.

Talk about not letting it drop, can someone throw a bone instead! Thanks for peeing on my excitement for my upcoming trip. Got any cheerful stroke or heart attack reviews to cheer us up with whilst your at it.

Oh, and please don't let the OP spoil your excitement. I think that you, like everyone I know in real life, will find the Disney on site resorts an absolute delight. That's why so many people return onsite trip after trip-- because we've found something very special there. Not because we've found someone who found something to complain about, but because our own experiences have proven to be so very positive.

My advice to you is to ignore this thread. If it ever did have a point, that point was lost the moment the OP decided against staying on site but continued to argue. And the evidence is quickly mounting that the intent of thread was actually something else altogether.
 
I think if you realize that these "resorts" are part of a theme park, your expectations will be more realistic.
Resorts elsewhere mean something entirely different. The amenities and services offered at WDW are sparse in comparison to what other vacation destinations offer.
Most people go to WDW for the parks. Most people stay at WDW for the location factor and onsite guest perks. Perks are really limited to easier ways to navigate your stay.
Most people spend little time at their hotel and on their respective grounds. Going to the parks is a full day easy, add in dinner and fireworks and you are getting back to your room just in time to go to bed.
All guests should be able to expect at least clean and working rooms. If you drive down and stay at a Holiday Inn Express on your way, you will most likely get a clean and working room, what you expect. I would say not to expect much more than that. At any level of resort, no matter what you pay. I can understand the frustration from guests, especially those in the deluxe resorts. Especially if you do not book your vacation six months in advance and find yourself not able to eat at your resort outside of the quick options. That would make me mad too! But the better places to eat are filled with people from every other resort and off site guests can eat there as well. WDW is awesome, but you do need to go there with realistic expectations. In my opinion it is a given that this will be a high energy vacation. There will be crowds of excited, busy people everywhere you go. This is not a vacation for me if I am wanting to relax and take it easy. Or have fresh, amazing food. Not saying that the food is bad per se, but you do have to remember the sheer amount of output that comes with 365 day a year service delivery.Maybe think of the table service places as nicer chains, like a Cheesecake Factory or someplace similar. They are not places where the Chef's reputation is riding on each diner's experience. I would just keep in mind why you are there, to experience WDW and realize that mishaps can happen if nothing more than the crazy amount of guests each day, every day and hopefully if you have concerns they will be addressed.
 
Regardless of what you are reading reviews for (wether it's gummy bears or a car or a movie) there is always going to be at least one less than perfect review. Like people said, sometimes things just happen because nothing is perfect. Not everyone likes or expects the same things. While finding a pair of dirty underwear in your room is obviously a non ideal situation, it's obviously something any hotel in general makes sure to avoid. If there were lots and lots of reports about people finding dirty underwear in their rooms or tons of rooms at the same time with lots of bugs, then it would be a legitimate concern for me. If the bad reviews don't seem to be the norm, if the good are more than the bad, the negative should be taken with a grain of salt. People let one thing they don't want to hear ruin all the good things they have heard about a place. You've clearly heard good things about Disney resorts and that's why you've been looking into them.
 
Patty, just because a few posters on this board say their rooms were clean doesn't necessarily make it the truth for all of the rooms at a resort. One of these posters on this thread said their room smelled like vomit, and they had to wear socks just to walk on the carpet. You don't think that is a problem? I highly doubt all of these reviews were false especially when they post pictures of bugs in their review, and all have consistent themes.

Having worked at hotels, I can honestly say that there is no way you will ever find a "spotless" hotel room. This is for a number of reasons but here are just a few simple explanations as to why you will never find what you are looking for.

1. Bugs pick where they want to live, not the owners or operators or even staff of the hotel. I am not saying it is not gross by any means, because it is and honestly it is off-putting. But lets be honest here in that you have probably found numerous spiders, ants, flies etc in your own bed or on your walls at home. Again, it is off putting but I'm sure no CM put that bug in your bed.

2. Dirt on the floors. How many times have you tried to scrub your own floor and home and can't get the darn dirt out of the grout in your tiles?!? If you answer that you get it out every time please tell me your secret!

3. Carpets. People spill things, kids puke, people wear their shoes in the room. That is why there are stains and that is why it is dirty. (Have you met your feet after you walk around Disney in flip flops? One word! Ew... yea you put that on the carpet too) and stainwise- at home if someone spills grape juice you clean it right away or else its there to stay. At a hotel when someone spills they grab a towel from the bathroom and they get up what they get up. Not everyone calls housekeeping "come quick, I spilled coffee it needs to be treated now". I mean in all honesty its not your house or your responsibility at a hotel so why would you call. I get it, but be understanding.

4. Dirty light fixtures and slow drains. Housekeepers get paid minimum wage typically and 9 times out of 10 they are given at least one too many rooms to clean. You want early check-in, you've got it, dusty lights and all. They rush to accommodate you. Want a clean room? Check in after check-in time when a majority are done and there is less stress on the housekeeper. Slow drains? I don't know about you but as long as the hair in my shower at home is hiding I'm good! When it is inside the tub or starts coming up the drain that is when I have a problem.

5. Room Changes- I get it. You see a bug, there's a puke stain on the carpet, there's a poop stain on the toilet- you want a room change! Hi, my name is Amanda- lowly front desk/ reception worker- how can I help you? "oh my god I want my room comped I saw a bug, my toilet won't flush, etc. Give me a new room and a discount" Ok! Now this girl who is generally very accommodating now wants you to get out of my hotel. I won't say that because I will act polite. But it is really all in the tone that you use with front desk workers/ CMs (at disney). I understand that you are upset but screaming at me and demanding a refund will not help! (Again, see how I did not place the bug inside your bed, it was the one that decided it wanted to live there) The nicer and more calm you are, the nice and more calm we are. If you say "hey, I wanted to tell you that room 301... well, i think it should be fumigated.. Is there any way that I could possibly have a new room?" this is probably a response you will get from us "Oh wow, thanks for notifying us, I'll call up the bug-killer right away and have him get on that. Here's a key for room 104, Do you need help taking your luggage there instead?" Yeah wow how nice.

6. Inability to change rooms/ room requests- So here's the deal on this: Sometimes (i.e. peak periods, holidays etc) hotels are booked solid. As in, if some freak snowstorm happened, and I had to stay at the hotel I would have to rest my head at my managers desk. We have nowhere else to put you, sorry. I get it if you have a late flight, but if you are out at the bar and walk up to my desk intoxicated and request a room change and I have no rooms available, you sir are out of luck, and I will come upstairs with my gloves on and unclog your sink. Things like this cannot be changed. It's not our fault blame corporate, we want to sell out the rooms that is how we make our money. And if you are really displeased we would call a sister hotel and have you transferred, we would even drive you there. Now for my favorite! Room requests! Everyone wants the best view in the house, at Disney they can guarantee you one of the best but you'll pay extra. Hey at least you know you'll be looking at the garden and not the concrete right? But you need to know that you still are not guaranteed the best view in the house, especially not if you want a microwave and a rollaway bed and a second floor room with a balcony and extra towels and shampoo and the list could go on. In my opinion. Set your sights low anytime you go to a hotel and just get more and more pleased anytime something is good. Go in there expecting to have bedbugs, and floor stains, and cobwebs, and be staring directly at a pavement jungle. Also expect that it will be either as hot as the sun or as cold as Antarctica. And then...... when you walk in and the curtains are pulled open and the sun is shining on the bug-free bed and the scent that you smell is windex be happy!

Really people! It is all about expectations!! Lower them, not just for hotels but for anything and you will see how nice your outlook can actually be. Disney is the happiest freaking place on Earth!!! But only if you allow it to be. If you go in thinking "well I just paid $100 to get in now I have to dump $70 on food at least, and I have to wait in a 90 minute line to ride a 5 minute long ride. Then I will have to listen to my kid screaming because she wants her picture taken with Belle..." (again the list could go on, and honestly it is all true, I'm not saying that at all.) that will be how your day goes, but if you go in and say "ok, I'm here on vacation lets make the best of it and run to the castle like a 4 year old, then you my friend... well, you should take me with you"


So to wrap it up. Life's what you make it (so lets make it rock!.. Lol Hannah Montana anyone? no, no takers? ok...) Enjoy the fact that you can:
A. afford to go to a Disney Park
B. afford to stay at a Disney Resort
and C. Have the right to post whatever you want about either.

But if you don't want to listen to these reasons. PM me I can give you 90 more!!

Best of luck if you do still decide to stay if not I'd gladly enjoy the rooms for you!

:worship:
 
This is my response to the OP. OP, keep in mind that this post is solely my opinion.

I took your posts to boil down to 2 issues -
1. Cleanliness of WDW resort rooms, and
2. Due to the low quality of WDW resort rooms, are the rooms worth $500.

I think your continued posting was a result of frustration - got lots of "I didn't have any problems, so there's no probleml" (realize this is a summary).
Think about spousal communication frustration. Spouse 1 - "I simply asked you to clean the toilet & look at it. It's still dirty!" Spouse 2 - "Looks clean to me."

OP, I say -
1. Yes, some (& sometimes many) of Disney's resort rooms are below par on cleanliness & updating.
2. No, when compared to $500 rooms elsewhere (*see "unless" exception below) WDW resort rooms are not worth $500 a nite. A $500 a nite room elsewhere would be much more plush - *unless Location is an issue, such as a high $ area - NY, LV, etc.

Why do lots of people pay $300 to $500 a nite at WDW? Location - just like in high $ areas - location, location, location.

So, OP, as long as staying at WDW is more important to people than the room, Disney wins. The bean counters will continue to determine the curve for how costs can be kept low before people start going elsewhere. Hasn't happened yet.

I hope this helps answer your concerns & questions.
 
OP hasn't been back. Like I've stated, a Troll.

You like calling people names? I am not a troll just because I have a different view point on the Disney Resorts, and I can't get on here everyday to respond to some of the posts. Some of the other DIS board members have had some very good points in their posts about the Disney Resorts, and I respect their opinions, and appreciate them. Your post not so much.
 
Will be my first time alone on property, Saratoga Springs ( hols been gifted to me for my 50th ) was really excited about it until reading this thread, am a bit glum now : (

Easygoinggeezer, I am sure you will have a great time!! Like other posters have posted it is Disney World, Just go in with lower expectations like RedHotAriel said in a prior post. I am a bit surprised that other DIS board members haven't chimed in about the Saratoga Springs Resort. It has some of the worse reviews online of the Disney Resorts, and it looks to have one of the longest trips/transportation to get to the area parks from the resort.
Safe travels.
 
Just ignore the haters. I can assure you that every Disney resort, regardless of the going rate per night, positively oozes magic and fairies. In fact, they're the cleanest and most technologically advanced rooms on the planet. The staff is the best-looking in the industry and nothing bad happens there. Ever.

Remember, Fantasyland is but one part of the WDW experience, not the entirety.




And I quote:

"Every resort, regardless of the going rate per night, positively oozes magic and fairies. The staff is the best-looking in the industry and nothing bad happens there. Ever. "

Okay, can I have some of that fairy dust please? LOL

Wow.. just wow.

Just tell that to these people who reviewed their stay at the Saragota Springs Resort that nothing bad ever happens.



We stayed here the week ending July 14th. The Resort grounds are beautiful the pool was great, but the rooms are disgusting. I never stayed in a place this dirty before. I have a timeshare and this was our 1st and last exchange vacation in this place. We had a one bedroom suite with full kitchen. Everything in that place was dirty, starting with the carpet so worn out that I kept slipping on it, ending with windows and curtains. This place is under Deluxe Villas on Disney website, it’s nowhere close to being deluxe. The windows were smeared with dirty handprints from the vacationer who stayed there before us. The unit had Jacuzzi, but when we turned it on it spewed dirt, upon closer inspection, we found it to be very dirty inside each opening, and needless to say we couldn’t use it. The window curtains had many stains on them. The AC vents had visible chunks of dirt/dust flapping in between the grills of the vents. Kitchen was full with pots and pans, and they were sitting in cabinets DIRTY!!!.



First of all best western blows this place out of the water! It smelled of old moth balls and the carpet was straight out of the 1960's. The shower in the room next to ours leaked into our room and flooded the carpet. The resort did nothing about this! The cafe, Artists Palette had chicken nuggets that sat there for two days and the rest of the food looked like it was 2 days old straight out of an elementary lunch room! If you are single with no children spend the extra money and UPGRADE to The Grande Floridian or for heavens sake find a Four Seasons!!!


This hotel was aweful compared to any other place we have stayed in Disney and frankly one of the worst hotels I have ever stayed. From check in with stressed and less than friendly front desk staff to arriving in our room to find the kids beds not made. We called the housekeeping who told us that "there are sheets in the closet and we should make the bed ourselves!", no kidding. So my wife didn't complain and grabbed the sheets to make the bed only to find there were dried "BUGS" in the sheets. We called again to get fresh sheets and they did come make the bed. The next morning we woke up to realize we had no toilet paper. I did go to the front desk and when I said i was not happy with the way we were treated and unhappy with the hotel itself the manager handed me the house phone and told me I could call disney guest services to inquire about staying somewhere else, he didn't even ask why i wasn't happy or if there was anything he could do. The room was worn and not very clean. They didn't even clean it the day before check out so we had no clean towels. It was just horrendous. I have never written a comment here before and am not that picky but this was just over the top bad and it was obvious that this was the norm. There are plenty of nicer hotels in the area and will only stay at a Non Disney resort next time.

This have to be one of the worst experiences in hotel acomodations, we were in Congress park in the 2 bedroom unit. It was dirty, mold in the bathrooms, had not been dust in months. After 6 days in the place they leave the linens for you to change them because is according to housekeeping a " home away from home" . While undressing the bed discover the mattress cover with large blood stain. Horrible and to think my 4 year old was sleeping in such filth. We complain and all they said what can we do for you now. No apology nothing. I understand Disney is suffering with the economy but that is no way to treat guests. Next time I stay out of this resort. Is convenient but very dirty. Housekeeping need to be improve.


Bad service. Both bed mattresses had to be changed, they were worn out, glass door slide also had to be repaired, door wouldn't slide. Black mold on tile in bathroom. The "Do Not Disturb" sign was on the door knob but housekeeping still tried to steal our groceries. They were packaged and in a shopping bag. I came back to the room to make lunch and found the bag in the hall covered with trash from our room. Because the food was packaged we were able to salvage it, but we were livid and he/she had deliberately trespassed! Because of the debacles we weren't able to leave our room much while the repairs were going on and we didn't trust the employees anymore.


The restaurants were disgusting, the whole place needed a good clean.


The room was small and dirty and the bathroom was disgusting.


We've stayed at almost every WDW hotel and this by far, was the worst one. An hour later, we finally got settled into a third room. This hotel is isolated from everything and offers nothing noteworthy as compared to animals at Animal Kingdom, ambience at Boardwalk/Beach/Yacht Club etc... We have told many who have asked about where to stay to avoid Saratoga. There's got to be a reason why SS is usually available when others are booked.


Then there was the issue with my room phones not working for 3 days. When I told management to come after 12 noon, they decided to show around 11 when my wife was not properly prepared for such a visit. Disaster after disaster. Food was bad, gift shop Terrible. Staff unhelpful. No theme whatsoever in this place other than 1 bronze horse at the entry by the lobby. Pool was lacking, slide closed early despite signs to the contrary, no explanation offered. Never stay there. Could not be more disappointed. Worst Disney accommodations ever and this was our 12th trip. Avoid this place at all costs.
 
I'm amazed to see this thread still going.

The OP has decided not to stay on site because of reviews of resorts she's never been to. It's a done deal; she's not going there, based on those reviews. That's great; each of us does what we think is best for our families.

Yet she continues to respond to positive reviews of those same resorts, contradicting the actual first hand experiences of posters with reviews from anonymous sources. For resorts she's not considering. And that she has never been to.

I can't imagine the logic. Once you've made your decision, why on earth would you continue an argument about the choices you've decided against? Why not move on with your trip planning, with your family, with your job, with other more important things-- with life? Why continue to argue just for the sake of arguing, particularly if what you're bringing to the "discussion" is someone else's experience and not your own.

It just makes no sense to me. Not for an adult with no other agenda. The only logical conclusion is that the OP is not an adult without an agenda. Either he/she is a child with too much time on his/her hands, or there's something else going on. But these are not the actions of an adult trying to discern the best place for her family to stay on vacation.



Oh, and please don't let the OP spoil your excitement. I think that you, like everyone I know in real life, will find the Disney on site resorts an absolute delight. That's why so many people return onsite trip after trip-- because we've found something very special there. Not because we've found someone who found something to complain about, but because our own experiences have proven to be so very positive.

My advice to you is to ignore this thread. If it ever did have a point, that point was lost the moment the OP decided against staying on site but continued to argue. And the evidence is quickly mounting that the intent of thread was actually something else altogether.

AliceAnn, there is no agenda, and yes I am an adult. I just have a different opinion then most of you do on here, and people that LOVE Disney have a heard time hearing an opinion that may some way distort their image of these Disney Resorts. You get defensive, and think its arguing when I am just discussing/giving a different view point on these resorts.

The majority of these reviews online are not anonymous. They have people's names and/or have been verified by the review sites.

Why aren't you being honest with Easygoingeezer about the Saratoga Springs Resort? At least tell him that the transportation to the parks from the resort is horrible/long.
 
This is my response to the OP. OP, keep in mind that this post is solely my opinion.

I took your posts to boil down to 2 issues -
1. Cleanliness of WDW resort rooms, and
2. Due to the low quality of WDW resort rooms, are the rooms worth $500.


I think your continued posting was a result of frustration - got lots of "I didn't have any problems, so there's no probleml" (realize this is a summary).
Think about spousal communication frustration. Spouse 1 - "I simply asked you to clean the toilet & look at it. It's still dirty!" Spouse 2 - "Looks clean to me."

OP, I say -
1. Yes, some (& sometimes many) of Disney's resort rooms are below par on cleanliness & updating.
2. No, when compared to $500 rooms elsewhere (*see "unless" exception below) WDW resort rooms are not worth $500 a nite. A $500 a nite room elsewhere would be much more plush - *unless Location is an issue, such as a high $ area - NY, LV, etc.

Why do lots of people pay $300 to $500 a nite at WDW? Location - just like in high $ areas - location, location, location.

So, OP, as long as staying at WDW is more important to people than the room, Disney wins. The bean counters will continue to determine the curve for how costs can be kept low before people start going elsewhere. Hasn't happened yet.

I hope this helps answer your concerns & questions.


Very good post TwoatDisney!! And thank you to some of the other people that posted some very good posts on the Disney Resorts. Pretty good points.
 
I would not be looking at the villas myself (although I am a happy owner), they are just not generally maintained or refurbished like the cash resorts. Which I am good with since I would be paying for that.

Hotels 7-12 are Disney resorts. Seems pretty good to me. Since staying at the Ritz, the Waldorf or even the Peabody and the like are not going to happen when I go to WDW, those really aren't relevant to me. And comparing them to all the hotels in the country, while it might help you determine what to expect compared to other places you've been or know about, doesn't really have any bearing if you're comparing Orlando hotels, does it? You only care about what's in Orlando.


vicki_c,

I am just curious if you have ever tried to stay off site at The Peabody ( sadly it was sold this past Sept to the Hyatt :sad1: ), the Ritz Carlton, or the Waldorf Astoria? If you time it right, you could book a room at these hotels anywhere from $250-350 a night. We stayed on the club level at the Peabody one trip for only $249/night, and it was phenomenal experience. The Waldorf Astoria is right in the back yard of Disney. You should see the pools and lazy rivers some of these hotels have.

I'd be curious to see how many of you have actually given any of these hotels a try so you could compare the quality/value of them to the Disney Resorts. I understand the location argument but how far is the Waldorf Astoria from Disney (1-2 miles ) if you can save $1,500-2,000, and stay at a true 5 star hotel.

So how many of you have given any of those 3 hotels a try?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.




New Posts







Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE














DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top