We're going to stay at all of the resorts at least once. I think it's fun to try them all! That said, I definitely have preferences among them. I'll break my feelings down into three categories:
The Good
1. Coronado Springs - I've always loved all things Hispanic. I think the resort is beautiful, love the pool, and had a great time here!
2. Polynesian - This often flips back and forth with Coronado for being my "favorite". I've also always loved all things hula/beach. I love the location, dining, colors. Can't wait to stay here for my first time in March!
3. Grand Floridian - Haven't stayed here yet. I just have always thought it's really pretty, love the location. Hopefully will be staying here for our 2 year anniversary in August.
4. Caribbean Beach - Very similar to Polynesian, stayed here the first night I was married - can't wait to experience it as a longer stay in March.
5. Wilderness Lodge - Haven't stayed here yet. I just like the atmosphere and decor here.
6. Animal Kingdom Lodge - Haven't stayed here yet. I think it will cool to look out of my balcony and see animals.
7. Beach Club - Haven't stayed here yet. Stormalong Bay seems awesome and I love the colors they've used here. Has the beach theme that I love.
8. Old Key West - Haven't stayed here yet. Again with the beach theme.

I think the wood work and colors here are really interesting and I love the sand pool!
The "Eh" (Don't hate, but not as intrigued)
9. Yacht Club - Haven't stayed here yet. I just don't like the colors as well as Beach Club, and since it shares a pool I'd rather be at Beach Club.
10. Swan/Dolphin - Haven't stayed there yet. I have always been intrigued by the buildings, but hesitate styaing there because of the lack of dining plan.
11. Boarwalk Inn - Haven't stayed here yet. Hasn't ever really jumped out at me and the clown kind of creeps me out.
12. Contemporary - Haven't stayed here yet. The theme seems bland here - I can get the excitement of the monorail at Grand Floridian or Polynesian.
The Bad
13. Saratoga Springs - Haven't stayed here yet. I just don't feel like it really has much of a "theme" or anything too special.
14. Fort Wilderness - My parents LOVE camping and I've been here several times. I hate camping with a passion and have no desire to ever camp again. I've never stayed in the cabins, but they don't seem that special to me - I've been in cabins elsewhere and I wouldn't use the kitchen.
15. All Stars/Pop - I've been to All Star Music and Pop, husband hasn't been to any. The biggest things I hate about them is the buses and lack of hot tub. Plus, they all seem the same to me and I kind of feel "been there, done that" about them.
16. Port Orleans Riverside/French Quarter - We've been to Riverside, but not to French Quarter. The theme just doesn't jump out to me at these and the bus service wasn't as good as the other places I've stayed.