Thanks for the info. I just called the person that gave the gift and they said that they'll look for the receipt.
I can understand stores not taking back used items but these games are still shrink wrapped with the Barnes and Noble stickers still on. My DD is too old to be invited to birthday parties and I'd hate to re-gift something and have that person stuck with the gift if they didn't want it.
Just to clarify, we weren't asking for a refund just an exchange or merchandise credit to buy something else in the store.
I know there is a lot of cases of people stealing things and then trying to take the items back. That is why most places require a recepit