1) the makeup of your group --- ages, genders, etc.
Two adults, two middle school aged sons
2)
DVC resorts you have stayed in (so we know which were in contention)
BLT, BWV, SSR, VWL, AKL
3) your ranking
My rankings: BWV, SSR, VWL, AKL
We didn't use the BLT pool, so I can't comment. Of the others, Boardwalk is our favorite. It isn't the nicest, but it has a great vibe to it during the day. SSR has a very nice main pool, but the vibe isn't the same. It was similar at VWL. I can't really comment on AKL since we only swam there at night.
I am looking forward to trying BCV this summer. We illegally pool hopped there years ago when our friends were staying there. Actually, maybe it wasn't illegal since we were visiting friends (not sure). It was nice, but we felt it was too spread out with too many places where we couldn't see our kids, who were young at the time.
I am more about the overall atmosphere (the energy) around the pool than the actual looks of it. SSR is a nicer pool than BWV, but BWV seems way more fun. Time and time again, we have had a better afternoon there.