Quiet Romantic WDW (sig?) Restaurant?

[Grumpy92]

Citricos at GF

 

[bedogged]

First off...big apologies for the huge post/thread starter. Anyway...

I'm looking for a restaurant to take my girlfriend to for her birthday on July 9th. We'll be staying in either WL, BC, or BWI for July 7th to 13th. We're both in our 20's and I know what she likes...so it's easy to make her birthday dinner amazing. ( I think..lol).

Right now I have reservations made for San Angel Inn...I know she loves mexican food, and it's been known as being romantic on some other sites around on the internet. But here's the thing: I'm looking for quiet. And i'm looking for a (semi)secluded table. I really don't wanna be in arm's reach to the diners next to us. We went to Cheesecake Factory up here in New York last week on a Friday night, and well...I can imagine it'd be THAT packed in WDW 2nd week of July. And it was a disaster. The food was great, but the tables were literally right next to eachother...the tables had just enough room to walk in between and it was so loud, my girlfriend and I couldn't even hear each other, and I'm terrified of a similar scenario in WDW for her birthday dinner. The other dinners during the week....eh...I can deal lol. But her birthday dinner should be special. I might even propose to her that night...*hint hint*.

Now...as for cuisine! Seafood is basically out. Narccoosee's (spelling? ...) and Citrico's is out because of that...I mean if it's a restaurant with some seafood, that's cool because then she still has options. California Grill looks pretty good, with the flatbreads and stuff, but that..along with Artist Point's menus look pretty intimidating. The items look like something my girlfriend..I don't think...would eat. She'll eat steak, but not choose it if she had other choices. She'll eat salmon, and shrimp. But no other fish or shellfish. If it's some sort of chicken, pork, or beef, she'll eat that.

I know i know....it's complicated. But I really cherish you guys' opinions!!

I'm a guy (AKA steak man lol). Even though it's her special day..maybe I can talk her into Yachtsman, Shula's, or Le Cellier! hehe...

Thanks guys!

I know you are getting suggestions for a lot of different restaurants, but I wanted to add another one. If you stay at Wilderness Lodge, please consider Artist Point. It is much quieter than a lot of the signature restaurants and has salmon as a signature dish.

 

[Simba's Mom]

We love Artist Point. We've celebrated our wedding anniversary there several times. We've often gotten personalized menus and always a lovely table. DH and DDIL celebrated at California Grill once and thought it was rather loud and "bustling".

 

[drj898]

I'll be staying at BWI. Not WL. And ill probably be taking her to Il Mulino at Swan. Looks perfect. I'll request a quieter alcove to eat in with her. Thanks everyone!