They are decent boots. Are they for you or John? Do you need steel toe? What are they for - around the house or for work? How many hours a day will they be worn?
I know I'm asking alot of questions, and boots can be expensive, but some employers will help cover the cost. Red Wings are very good. So are Chippewas. A good pair of Chippewas will run you about $150; same for Red Wings, but they last. Steel toes cost more.
The best thing to do is try them on for comfort. Some can have higher tops than others and if you are not used to it, they can be stiff and rub your calves. The best thing to solve that is not to lace the up all the way to the top.
I don't have to wear steel toes, so I wear a good pair of Timberland hiking boots to walk around jobsites on. My boyfriend is on his 2nd or 3rd pair of Chippewas and he loves them.
Rocky also makes good boots. I bought a pair of those for snowshoeing, hiking and work since the weather is so bad up here this year. They are stiff around the ankles, but I needed them to be.