DH and I just returned from a weekend at the Dolphin. The hotel is very nice, has a lot of great dining choices, very nice pool and large rooms with SUPER comfortable beds. The great thing about the hotel was that it was only a tad more expensive than a Disney Moderate but we had the great location of an Epcot Resort. Swan & Dolphin guests are entitled to Extra Magic Hours as well as Disney transportation to and from the theme parks. However, that's where the similarities end. You don't get Magical Express, Airline Check In or the option to use the
DDP. Also, when we checked in we didn't receive our usual Disney schedules which details all of the theme park hours, Extra Magic Hours and other events throughout the Disney resort. I found this very frustrating because I'm accustomed to planning out my day and using those materials given at check in. I also found it MUCH more of a hassle to have to do Airline Check In at the airport. The lines were huge, we had to return a rental car and drag our luggage through the airport which we don't normally have to do when staying at a Disney Resort. For us, even though we really enjoyed our stay at the Dolphin, it just isn't worth the extra hassle to have to rent a car, check our own bags at the airport, not have the DDP, etc. If you don't normally use those extra 'perks' Disney provides then I think the Swan & Dolphin would be an excellent choice. IMO, Swan/Dolphin is a GREAT alternative to staying offsite, but if you're used to staying onsite at a Disney Resort it just isn't the same.