I understand completely what you mean about a resort not being for you. It happened to us at AKL last year. Everyone made is seem so perfect but it wasn't for us. Never be afraid to share your opinion as it can help other people!
Its true! I'm sorry you didn't love AKL,though. Its on my must-stay (someday) list!
Ahhh! I forgot you were going to be there in October. I should have known better.

Did you end up going with the 2 bed at OKW? That is where we will be! LOVE OKW! The only thing I didn't have such a great experience with were the buses. We waited 40 minutes more than once....not happy. I hope that was just a fluke. The other thing was the craZy sidewalks. The sidewalks just abruptly end and then continue on the other side of the street. It's odd. And annoying with a little one in two. Thankfully there isn't much traffic, so it doesn't feel unsafe by any means...but still... Aside from those two things, BEAUTIFUL resort-oh my goodness. So lush and just pretty, pretty, pretty. We met some of the very nicest Cast Members, it's like they all were sprinkled with extra pixie dust or something there! We are really looking forward to going back.
Oh, and the rooms are HUGE! I'm sure you knew that one, but I had to throw it in there!

I can't wait to see the 2-beds.
Being I was obviously really far behind....great report! Sorry to hear the Poly didn't live up to your expectations. The dinged up furniture and plywood is ABSURD for that price point! Did you by any chance send that to Disney with your room number? They truly need to correct that. I've been reading a lot of rumors lately about a giant Poly refurb. I'm not following closely enough to say how legit it is...but it seems to be fairly solid. Like total refurb...putting in hot tubs, bigger pool, new rooms, and a whole new Grand Ceremonial House (since the thing is ancient and basically falling apart...). We'll see! It would be exciting.
Have a fantastic trip!!!
We did end up choosing OKW! What are your dates? We're there October 18th (really late that night) to the 22nd (when we have a pretty late flight home). So perhaps we can finally meet!
Everyone has told us the two bedrooms are huge! If its as nice as SSR was, I'll be a happy girl. I was quite suprised at home much I liked SSR. Still don't love the theme, but the whole place was just beautiful.
I'm much more into the theme at OKW, though, and we passed it everytime we went back to SSR, and what little of it I could see from the main road looked beautiful.
Speaking of meeting, I did end up getting my February vacation back!

Thank goodness! I was so bummed about the prospect of never having a vacation with Mark and Max again. Point being, I'd love to go that week, as our APs expire that Wednesday and I wouldn't mind having another day or two where we didn't go to a park at the end of our trip. While my husband hasn't said yes, he hasn't said no, either.

I mean, we have APs, its like we get to go for free!

We could very well be there that week, too!
As for the Poly...you put it perfectly...the situation in our room, in particular, was absurd for that kind of money. I feel like the Poly is sort of getting by on its location at this point.
I would love to see a massive refurb of it, though. They have great restaurants. Kona has quickly become one of my favorites. Obviously the location is magical. Where else can you get views of the castle like that? And I really love the theme. But that pool is ridiculously small...and whose idea was it to re-build the volcano pool without a hot tub???
That said, Mark did not like the theme, so its doubtful no matter what they do, that we'll ever stay there again. Mark loves the BC!

Sorry, I still get a kick out of the idea that my husband (whose frugal on a good day) is so in love with a deluxe resort.
Thanks...I've so excited for to have a whole eight days in Florida!