Potato salad, Macaroni salad, and Cole Slaw... Rank 'em.

[Papa Deuce]

according to how much you enjoy them.

Macaroni.... definitely #1

Potato... #2

Cole Slaw..... #3 ... I hate it.

 

[Mandychelle79]

Macaroni - 1

Coleslaw- 2

Potato Salad- 3 YUCK

 

[tazdev3225]

Potato salad #1
Macaroni and cole slaw are tied because I don't like or dislike them. Pasta Salad is a different story,

 

[OK!]

It totally depends on the recipe. I love all 3 of them, but out of my favorite permutations, I'd go with

1. macaroni salad
2. cole slaw
3. potato salad

 

[DISUNC]

#1 Potato Salad
#2 Cole Slaw if available....KFC has the BEST!
#3 & NEVER macaroni salad. I cant even touch cold macaroni. It reminds me of Dead flesh!

 

[OK!]

#1 Potato Salad
#2 Cole Slaw if available....KFC has the BEST!
#3 & NEVER macaroni salad. I cant even touch cold macaroni. It reminds me of Dead flesh!

Do we even want to know how it is that you're able to make that comparison?

 

[DISUNC]

Do we even want to know how it is that you're able to make that comparison?

When I was a kid, after my Aunts funeral my cousin told me that they use the body to make macaroni salad! It stuck all these years!

 

[The Mystery Machine]

Potatoe
Macaroni
Coleslaw

 

[KyraS]

Potato (with mustard!)
Cole Slaw (depends on where it's made)
Macaroni (can not even honestly tell you if I've ever had it.)

 

[4nana]

#1 my Potato Salad my SonIL's rave over

#2 my Mom's Cole Slaw is the best ever

#3 my DD's creative Macaroni is very yummy

 

[pppiglet]

according to how much you enjoy them.

Macaroni.... definitely #1

Potato... #2

Cole Slaw..... #3 ... I hate it.

I hear ya on all three!

 

[Planogirl]

1. Cole slaw - love it but light on the dresssing please

2. Potato salad - a good one is hard to beat

3. Macaroni - I've tasted few that I liked.

 

[rentayenta]

It totally depends on the recipe. I love all 3 of them, but out of my favorite permutations, I'd go with

1. macaroni salad
2. cole slaw
3. potato salad

Ditto.

 

[Papa Deuce]

Potato (with mustard!)
Cole Slaw (depends on where it's made)
Macaroni (can not even honestly tell you if I've ever had it.)

That's kind of where this poll came from. I just made a potato salad that I took from a BBQ book.... made with mustard... My wife and mom do not like it at all. I think it is pretty good!

4 pounds russet potatoes, boiled til soft, then skinned, and chopped.
1.25 cups of yellow mustard
1.25 cups of mayo
12 ounces of relish
3 TBS of black pepper
1 TBS salt
4 ounces of finely chopped celery
1 tsp celery seed
1/4 cup diced onions

Mix it all together and then "mash it" just a little bit, so you have hunks of potato as well as a little bit of creamy potato.

Don't use the skins for anything in the salad.

If I made it again I would only use 3/4 cup of mustard.....

 

[wishspirit]

1) Potato (esspecially with salad onions, give it a kick)
2) Coleslaw (but NOT the cheesy kind)
3) Macaroni (never tried, but i guess i has cheese in too? )

 

[suzimar57]

1 - macaroni

2 - coleslaw

3 - potato salad (ewwww!)

 

[MushyMushy]

macaroni
potato (which would be #1 if I could find just the right type)
cole slaw

I've only ever found 2 different types of potato salads I like. My sister's MIL makes a delicious one, and Max & Erma's used to have a good one. Other than that, they all taste too sweet for me.

 

[Pooh67_68]

Ditto

according to how much you enjoy them.

Macaroni.... definitely #1

Potato... #2

Cole Slaw..... #3 ... I hate it.

 

[Chattyaholic]

I guess it would depend on who makes them, what recipes they use, but my own recipes I would have to say:

1. Macaroni
2. Potato
3. Cole Slaw

I make a lot of macaroni and potato salads during the summer months.

 

[The Mystery Machine]

That's kind of where this poll came from. I just made a potato salad that I took from a BBQ book.... made with mustard... My wife and mom do not like it at all. I think it is pretty good!


If I made it again I would only use 3/4 cup of mustard.....

Instead of mustard use Durkees. Much better. Although I do not know the amount, I just kind of wing it. I know you would not need that much.