We recently returned from Port Orleans Riverside.
It was ok...but, I liked Pop Century better (we stayed there last summer). I didn't like the fact that Riverside shared a bus with POFQ. Of course, of the 5 bus stops (POFQ, Main Stop at POR South Depot, West Depot, North Depot, East Depot)...we were the last stop and the bus was always full or standing room only.
If I were to choose to stay in a moderate again....I would choose POFQ. It's small which means less walking and you are first on the pick up and drop off schedule for the bus which will virtually guarantee you a seat on the first available bus every time.
I haven't stayed at any other moderates....but, all the advantages I thought a moderate would have over a value turned out to be an afterthought....in my opinion, of course.
We had noisy neighbors for a few nights....that's just the luck of the draw. You can't blame a resort for the neighbors you have and it didn't really bother us that much.
I thought the bus service would be quicker since we were closer to MK and Epcot. But, since the buses have to make 5 stops compared to the Pop Century bus' 1 stop...the bus time ended up being about the same.
The food court was better at Pop in my opinion. More drink options (frozen coke) and the food was prepared better...of course, again....that's just the luck of the draw on who is cooking the food. I'm sure the burgers, chicken tenders, and pizza are the same at both resorts....it's just a matter of how it's cooked.
The boat to Downtown Disney is nice...but, a bus is faster. If you like a relaxing boat ride...then, it's something you will like.....but, we were hungry at the time and wanted to get there as quickly as possible....so, we took the bus.
The waterslide and waterfalls at the main pool close at 8pm....so, if you are late swimmers like us (we like to swim after returning from the park at about 9pm or 10pm)....then, the main pool offers no big advantage over any other value pool.
The fridge in the room is nice to have.
I know everyone thinks differently and has different tastes. We are the type of family that just wants a clean room with a bed and shower. We dont' spend much time exploring the resort...we are there for the parks. After trying a moderate for the first time, I've come to the conclusion that I will either stay value or at a monorail resort (if I could ever afford that) from now on. I don't think you get enough benefits for the 50% more that you pay staying at a moderate over a value. The only reason we tried it was because we had a pin rate of $79 compared to a pin rate of $59 at a value.
Of course...this is just my opinion. Everyone is different and you may end up loving the moderates.
POFQ would be the only moderate I would ever consider in the future. It is first on the bus route and is small for a lazy guy like me. Its layout is about the same as a value layout with many buildings very close to the main building. It also has no restuarant besides the food court.
Again...just my opinion.
Speed