We stayed at POFQ last fall, and we really liked it! It is a small resort, so there are no rooms that are far from the bus stops, food court, or pool. The boat that goes over to DTD is great- very relaxing. The rooms are nice- the whole resort was recently refurbished.
The only downsides to POFQ I can see are the lack of a sit-down restaurant and the theme. The restaurant thing can be remedied by taking a short stroll along the river to POR and eating there. As for the theme- I loved it, but for some, it might be a bit too quiet and low-key for them. If you want an upbeat, fast paced, "fun" theme to your resort, POFQ might be too quiet for you. But if you like to go back to a tranquil, quiet resort, then the New Orleans theme is great.
I loved POFQ, and would stay there again in a heartbeat! I haven't been to all of the Mods, but between POFQ and CSR, I'd choose POFQ.