Hi all! I booked my first stay at Pop with RO discount for the first week in December! I have only been to WDW once before in August 2012 and we thought it would be our ONLY trip for years so we went all out and stayed AKL. However I fell in love with WDW and didn't want to leave. So because we spent so much last time we figured if we wanted to visit again so soon we'd have to go value. I debated on going mod but even with discounts a mod was 500 more than Pop. Also last time we didn't fully enjoy AKL bc we spent ALL of our time in the parks. We basically just slept at AKL. Pop just looks like a fun resort too. It is just DH and I so we're a little worried about the noise level but hopefully we will love it and it will be the perfect fit for us since we spend all our time at the parks anyway.
Noise can be a factor anywhere you stay, really. Yes, POP might be a bit more chaotic at times, but I have yet to experience a situation where I couldn't sleep or where things didn't settle down at night. After midnight, it's very peaceful. If you plan on getting up early (7 AM or so) I don't see there being any issues whatsoever. If you sleep in when everyone is getting up and little kids are running all over the place, it can get a bit noisy in the morning or during the day. But all in all, I've never had any problems with the noise.
I want to call and make my room recommendations but I'm debating on what to ask for. I want a 'quiet location' if possible. Lake view seems like a good request but I'd rather be in the 50s/80s/90s section so I feel like if I request lake view I might get 60s or 70s. 50s I want just for Lady and the Tramp. I love that movie! 80s and 90s section bc DH and I are big geeky gamers and the thought of a computer pool is just too cool to resist. Also I was born in 80 and he in 76, so we are both children of the 80s (and 90s teens) so I think we'd really enjoy that 'memorabilia' best. I am almost tempted to JUST ask for 80s and 90s but I also really want to stay in 50s too.
Decisions decisions...

Any suggestions?
Keep in mind that if you check in online you can make 2 requests, and over the phone they may let you make more.
Some people like to ask for 4th floor for less noise, since you won't have anyone above you. I like the 50s section, too. If you booked a standard room and you request lake view, you'd likely get 50s, 60s, or 70s.
If it were me, I'd request 50s and lake view, and just hope I don't get a noisy family above me. Even then, like I said, I've never had any problems from maybe about midnight to 6:00 AM, which is my most critical sleeping time. If you call in, they
might let you add 3 requests, in which case you could go Lake View, 50s, and 4th floor. That sounds like what would be ideal for you.
The 80s/90s section is probably the shortest walk to the buses because you have a chance to cut across the parking lot straight to the buses. That's probably the biggest benefit of that section. But I like the slight nostalgia feeling of the 50s decade, and I love the look of the Lady and the Tramp and the jukebox more than the computer and things at the 80s/90s section.