We stayed at the Poly this past June and the GF just a couple of weeks ago. We had a standard room at the GF and it had a balcony, but I don't know if they all do. The bell hop told me that the rooms had recently been redone, and I thought they were gorgeous. The beds were so comfortable. Our GF room also had a split bath, which our Poly room didn't. The restaurant choices are great, but we still took the monorail back to Ohana's and Kona because we loved them so much the trip before. If you eat at the food court frequently, though, I thought the GF's was even smaller than the Poly's. We went to the Beach Pool at the GF while we were there-the slide was okay, but not as neat as the volcano one at the Poly according to my kids. Okay, so after all of that, I would have to say that I liked the theme better at the Poly, but the GF room was better. I hope maybe this helps. We have stayed at a different resort every time we have been to Disney, because I think it is neat to try something new. But, you definitely can't go wrong either way!