Not to wade into a debate on the subjective merits of one property versus another...
But, how people feel about each individual DVC Resort is going to have about as many opinions as there are owners. Truth is that they are all great and individually, we are all going to have our preferences. For instance, now that our DD is in college, it's usually just DW and I traveling. That means a lot of studios. For those, we actually prefer BLT. Yes, it's small, but A) it has a great location, B) we think it has the best layout of any studio, especially the kitchenette area, which we use a lot, and C) it has easy parking which is important for us since we drive.
Now Aulani, we won't go unless we get at least a 1-bedroom because we feel like you have to have a kitchen in Hawaii as food is so expensive. In fact, we have always gotten a 2 bedroom and invited friends/family. It is probably our favorite overall DVC (and it really isn't close). When Disney got rid of AP's we figured it was actually cheaper to use our points in Hawaii than go to WDW, even though WDW is about an 8.5 hour drive away. (ETA: that calculus has changed now that AP's are back on the table)
Our specifics are not everyone else's though, so we all have our likes and dislikes based on what our own circumstances are. Also, we really do like every property, though we have our preferences of one over another. And sometimes it depends on the room type. For instance, we like SSR for studios, but prefer OKW or AKV Standard for 1/2 Bedrooms if we are trying to minimize points. For splurges, we prefer PVB or VGF1, but don't really like VGF2 because you can "put" the second bed away, so you have no living area. However, others may love the 2 bed setup at either VGF2 or OKW studios.
But, this being an internet message board, it fun to blow things out of proportion...