So here is my preliminary itinerary, although I still haven't finished reading all of the material that I have been collecting over the last few months.
A few items of note since my last posts:
We switched our reservation from Le Centre Sheraton to Le Square Phillips. I got a much better rate, it will provide us with more room, and it has a full refrigerator and kitchen ( and NO I am not cooking any dinner meals...

...sorry thought you were my DH!)
I just looked, again, at the Just For Laughs Festival website and it looks like there are no shows playing at the end of July which is when we are going. Maybe that will change and I will keep my eye on it.
I am still going back and forth about the hop on hop off bus vs. the 3 hour tour. The more I learn about Montreal, the more I feel confident in the hop on/off bus....meaning my level of knowledge of the city, etc.
So here we go...
Day one: Arrive in Montreal via Amtrak at approx. 7:30 pm. Take a taxi (I will not drag my suitcases through the Metro - sorry I am spoiled I know...blame it on Magical Express

). Check in, unpack, dinner at Il Focolaio, pizzeria down the block from hotel.
Day two: 3 hour tour of montreal (Grayline) or the Hop on/off bus (Grayline). If we do the three hour tour (10am), we will then go shopping along Ste. Catharine and dinner around Rue Crescent. If we do the hop on/off (runs until 6 pm), we will still go shopping along the streets, but not as long.
Day three: Old Montreal. Archeology Museum, Science Museum, Cartier, considering Amphi bus fireworks tour or just watching them from the bridge.
Day four: Le Rhonde. I am applying my disney techniques and hoping this park will be less crowded the day after a fireworks competition show and it is the middle of the week. Keep your fingers crossed.

1/2 the group to the casino
Day five: Full day tour to Quebec city
Day six: Olympic Stadium, Biodome, Insectiarium, Planetarium Ghost Tours Old Montreal this night.
Day seven: Very up in the air at the moment. We may: sleep in alittle and do a brunch, then watch the drummers on Mont Royal followed by shopping on St. Denis. OR go to Jean Talon, then drummers, then shopping. OR sleep, brunch, shopping and forget about Mont Royal (we would be there on tour on day two...just not sure if that is enough time, although hop on/off would)
Day eight: Old Montreal again, things we didn't see and jet boating (kids want this)
Day nine: Travel home
I am still in the process of picking restaurants and I'd like to schedule an afternoon tea somewhere.
Honestly, any thoughts are appreciated!